Here’s the first sentence of a recent New Yorker article;
“God does not and cannot exist,’ Iris Murdoch once wrote, “but what led us to conceive of him does exist, and is constantly experienced and pictured.”
Hard to disagree with that sentiment. So I agree with it.
Which raises the question, what does lead us to conceive of a nonexistent god? There’s plenty of possible answers. Some that make sense to me are:
(1) A belief in some sort of supernatural being provided answers to questions that early humans had about the world that couldn’t be answered by science, because science didn’t exist yet.
(2) Religious belief fostered social solidarity among early humans, since it provided a shared cultural foundation for cooperative action among individuals.
(3) Fear of god was an effective way of enforcing moral rules established by a group of early humans. For if someone was able to break a rule in absolute secrecy, they still had to worry about a supernatural being having an eye on them.
(4) Given that consciousness feels ethereal and non-physical to us humans, it is easy to assume that some conscious aspect of us, like a soul, lives on after our body dies in a supernatural realm ruled by a divine being.
Of course, lots of people have never felt any inclination to either conceive of god or to believe in one of the gods conceived of by the world’s religions. I have friends who never have had the slightest interest in god and find it difficult to understand why other people do.
(I feel much the same way about hockey. I realize that many people like to play or watch hockey, but this sport is so uninteresting to me, it instantly came to mind when I thought, need an example of something I have no interest in.)
Actually, I’m not sure if the four reasons I offered above for why so many people are inclined to conceive of a nonexistent god are valid ones. Maybe there are on a broad societal or anthropological sense, but not on an individual sense.
I say this because I really have no idea why I didn’t believe in god for the first 22 years of my life, then I did believe in god for about 35 years, and now I’ve been a nonbeliever again for about 21 years. I can easily come up with reasons for both my religiosity and my atheism. However, I’m dubious that what I feel were the reasons really were what led me to shift between belief and disbelief.
We humans often are uncomfortable with not knowing.
We frequently prefer a comforting falsehood to a disconcerting I’m clueless about this. So we mistake what pops into our conscious mind when someone asks us “Why do you believe in god?” or “What made you leave your religion?” for what probably is the genuine much different unconscious reason.
But since it is unconscious, we’re faced with a choice hetween replying with I don’t know or supplying the popped-into-mind answer. I’m inclined to take the latter route, because I enjoy talking with people about atheism/religion and I don’t know tends to be a conversation stopper.
Well, unless those three words are followed by here’s why.
So here’s why I feel that I don’t know is often or usually the most scientifically valid response to a question about why we believe in, or don’t believe in, something. Simply put, the human mind is hugely complex. It’s been termed the most complex entity in the known universe. Tens of billions of neurons. Trillions of connections between the neurons.
And somehow most of us consider that much or all of the time we know what caused us to think, feel, or act in a certain way. In this regard we are a lot like AIs, artificial intelligences, who fairly often make stuff up (confabulate) rather than answer a user’s question with I don’t know. Nature abhors a vacuum, and both artificial and natural intelligences abhor the absence of reasons.
I believe in reasons. I believe in causes and effects. I believe that determinism rules the universe, and that where it doesn’t (as in some quantum phenomena) probability and randomness rule.
Importantly, it sure seems like the human mind is an example of a non-linear system. Meaning, small changes can have big effects. And possibly big changes can have small effects. Not so sure about that, but Google AI just told me:
Yes, big changes can have small effects. While people often talk about the reverse (small causes leading to massive consequences, like the butterfly effect), large actions or disruptions can sometimes result in minimal or muted impacts due to damping, resistance, or systemic absorption.
So I have no way of knowing how all of the little, big, and medium changes in my life contributed to me going from not believing in god, to believing in god, then to not believing in god. A tiny influence could have had an immense impact on me. I have no problem throwing out my conscious reasons. I do that frequently on this blog.
But deep down, I’m convinced that life is a mystery. For everybody. We humans have come to know a lot about the universe, yet there’s much that we don’t know. Both about the physical world outside of us and the mental world inside of us.
In my better moments, I’m able to embrace that mystery in a comfortable silence. In my not-so-good moments, I paper over the mystery with wordy guesses about what lies beneath the surface of my not-knowing.
Discover more from Church of the Churchless
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Brian’s four reasons to believe in God are logical enough, but as he admits: – “Actually, I’m not sure if the four reasons I offered above for why so many people are inclined to conceive of a non-existent god are valid ones. Maybe they are on a broad societal or anthropological sense, but not on an individual sense
I read this recently, which, needless to say, fits with my interpretations of belief and meaning and how this reflects my own habit of looking for patterns: “The psychology of belief reveals that our convictions are rarely the result of cold, hard logic. Instead, they are complex tapestries woven from emotional needs, social pressures, and biological shortcuts designed for survival rather than accuracy. The human brain is naturally wired to find patterns and meaning, and beliefs start to form early in life.”
To someone who believes in God, or Gods, or needs to believe in something ethereal, that would not fulfill the psychological needs we have imported from our physical survival needs. It is safer to justify and maintain our particular beliefs as they occupy a huge ground of what we believe or think we are – or would like to be.
It’s all quite similar to how the constructed self operates. Again, it is quite natural, in fact imperative, to maintain the physical organism in order to survive and pass on our genes. We animals go to amazing lengths to ensure our survival. As humans, we have evolved enough to be self-conscious, and have formulated a mental picture of who we are, mostly derived from our cultures and general life experiences.
This self-structure, this mental image of ‘me’ has become so dominant that we often value it more than our physical bodies. We defend and maintain this ‘self’ through our ideas about who/what we believe we are, which may help psychologically, though it can also open the door to beliefs in Gods, the afterlife, etc.
We argue and debate over our beliefs just as ferociously as we would defend our bodies. We would even wage war on those who held different and conflicting beliefs. We identify with our particular countries, our religious beliefs, in fact, any beliefs that appear to inform us who we are – and in this way we maintain and support the mentally formed structure of ‘me’.
You exist and your higher power Death exists so what more do you need except to continue the species.
Not believing in and not experiencing God, is the confirmation of being separated from ..separated by the senses…and …separated by the mind.
You are aware of everything around you in separation
You recognize them by concepts that are separated from one another.
That is a ..knowing, aware ..ME in separation from …???
We all know about gravity.
We use it daily.
We are aware of it.
But …
Does it exist?
Does it have an existence beyond the concept and the derived practical use?
Like the beatifull metaphor used by Bernardo Kastrup in his book “Analytical idealism” of a whirlpool … it is there in the water, it has power but no existence of its own … it is an attribute of movement
Just waiting for the official RSSB propaganda sponsorship comment from Spencer Tepper, which discredits any content unless it’s pro-RSSB. I’m sure they pay him well.
The payment is pure love, Anon.
For some love isn’t a real thing.
For others, it is all there is.
The endless hair splitting about what is God and do you believe is all pretty much wasted time unless you’re a fiction writer of some sort. But for the mimicking monks it might keep them from beating off or beating their wives.
Hi Brian
Existence as we know it is over rated.
As Plotinus wrote, the higher One cannot fit into any description and has no part of this creation and cannot be found here. From our perspective God (the personified version of this great power that created all things) doesn’t exist.
Relative to all that exists, he is non-existent. Certainly he is beyond mental conception.
But if you need to conceptualize, Tao’s teaching of Wu is a great way. God is the empty space in every jar that gives the jar any purpose at all. God is the empty void that gives the planets and the sub-atomic particles their positions and roles. God is the empty hub of the wheel that all the spokes rotate around, and without which there would be no wheel. God is the idea that cannot be held in your hands yet that grew the tree, and the city of towers, and beyond that design, the blank page from which it emerged.
As the emptyness that gives an things purpose and meaning, God doesn’t exist yet can be found in everything.
Does that help? God is the true reality from which this illusion emerged. The nind can’t conceive of the real. So, think of nothing, thinck of the empty space that gives all things place and purpose, and that takes you closer to the non-existent God who is eternal, was never born and has never died.
We ourselves become eternal merging in that non-existence out of sheer love.
I heard spence gave BBJ a BJ 😂
Sucks
This is that place, Sucks, where you can be you and I can be me. No shame in any of it. Proceed in your illusion and I’ll do the same. Though I much prefer mine.
Love or hate?
That is your choice.
Spence, Lol what a pretentious response 😂 like i said you dont have to try so hard to sound deep and intelligent. Its coming off desperate.
Sucks, your entire attention is to me personally.
Isn’t that a little desperate?
How about the topic of the blog?
Or is that too big for you?
Desperate is someone whos mind is too cowardly and cannot comprehend that sometimes bad things happen to good people and thats it. Its that simple. Desperate people resort to believing elaborate stories of multiple lives like video games, reincarnation, and of course, karma, when almost always, the simplest answer is the one thats most likely.
Desperate is also believing a con man with no tangible concrete evidence just to feel loved. What happened spence? Lets break it down. Didnt get enough love at home so you thought you’d try to get it from some sardar? I think youl eventually find the love one sided. At least the educated ones do, and eventually walk away. Otherwise, keep fooling yourself and continue sucking on your masters teet
But thats more like it, youre debating like a normal person and less with the philosophical nonsense. We come here for facts, not your delusional opinion 👳🏻♂️🙏🏼
Sucks
“We come here for facts”?
OMG hilarious!
Spence Tapper… of babajis ass,😂
Yes facts. We believe in science and evidence. And no, not psudoscience and heresay like karma and souls. Spare me the bullshit that there is proof of a soul because of some old report that one time when someone died some weight left an airtight room. Real science is consistent. If you drop an apple 100/100 times it will fall thus proving gravity.
Science and facts are NOT the same as taking the word of an indian billionaire (who probably doesnt even wear deodorant) to literally waste 2.5 hrs a day of your life meditating and fantasizing him, and then during q&a when the idiot followers keep crying to him and bawling like babies that nothing is happening during meditation, the best answer buttbaji could give them is something along the gist of theyre clearly not trying hard enough. Ive seen them desperately and genuinely cry their eyes out to him asking what to do, only for him to give some silly analogy as usual like “beta when a child is playing with his toy he will hardly give you attention, but take away the toy, blah blah…” basically theyre not trying hard enough. Terrible how he treats the masses just because they are uneducated. Id almost feel sorry for them if they werent so self righteous 😂
Oh and the fact that eggs are STILL banned alone proves how anti facts and science your cult is. but of course, lets not acknowlege this egg stuff and once again and just discuss plotinus and tao nonsense so that you can pat yourself on the back.
Spence mentioned the Tao and Wu [wei]. I have the translation from Arthur Waley’s Tao Te Ching (The Way and Its Power). It (Tao) cannot be conceptualised, as much as past translations attempt. What I appreciate about the word Tao (not the concept) is that it points to emptiness. Not the emptiness of nothingness but of potential or utility. Similar to how one can try to conceptualise the nothingness of space or the nothingness before the Big Bang.
There is the analogy of the pot only being useful because of its emptiness, or a house with solid walls and roof only being useful because of the space within – usefulness coming from what is not. The same could apply to our minds, being full of knowledge, beliefs and concepts. All valuable at some point but unable to reflect what is truly there for us when it is continually being overlaid with ‘mind stuff’.
Our habit is to overlay this emptiness, the ‘what is ’, with various concepts that effectively act as filters to reality. In this respect, the only reality we can truly know and be with is the reality of our daily existence – which, when applied to ourselves, our minds, is the emptiness of the Tao, the potential to ‘be’ with everything.
Nice summery.
Next step : Empty of even our daily existence might just be the basis of a new understanding.
Reading the start of this topic again and the attitude of people around you, simple not being interested my mind spontaneous reacted with:
You never had any interest in God, not before initiation, not in the 35 years afterwards, but … surprise, surprise ….NOW …you do!!
You have come to know about inter experiences, by your own use of psychedelic drugs, and the growing information you have about inner experiences, through biographies of saints, shamans etc and the scientific literature about near death experience as they occur on the operation table and are now widely discussed, documented and researched.
Sooner or later you come to see that the source of the concept us with individual experiences and as these experiences do have certain qualities in common, the concept is not empty
Then … the real problem starts.
The dichotomy is that you can’t prove God doesn’t exist either. So why argue or debate. What is your definition to start with? If it’s an old man with a beard then here I am.
If an indigenous tribes has no knowledge of the gadgets of modern society, how can they have a concept of these gadgets and longing for it?
What is true for other experiences.
Society an culture has always had problems with concepts that are individual and not available for all or functional for that society.
Mysticism has always been the ” black sheep”
and it will remain so.
If you, reader, have a lucid dream that is formative for you, who cares … who can care?
At most if your dream effects your behavior, those near and dear are interested
The rise of mysticism on the 70ties was functional in those days …
BEFORE….Before the advent of practices books, theory related to LUCID DREAMING …. there were ..spontaneous dreamers.
FIRST, came the experience, LATER, practice an theory was developed for the benefit of others.
And ..that … is the path of all other internal practice and related theory.
The rest is fantasy hearsay, table and saloon talk.
There is no reason why any common person should be interested if it not was advertised and promoted interested others…..you cannot buy not even a burger and a coffee for it.
Those that have real interest hide themselves from a society that does not want to spend a dime on it.
Would be
Fake
Interests
The lobby is done by the masses them self … THEY …spread the knows…ask Brian …how it was done at the universities and how he came involved …ask your new master
It has been as a PYRAMIDE game
He, Brian believed and drank the collet of (snake) oil to the bottom
And….
He, Brian became a skilled lobbyist.
And
So the oil spread all over the USA
Now he is selling a product to solve the oily grease …as always …with vigor
Um
In the absence of any escape, and any advertised path, when all the world has to offer has been exhausted, then and only then, the mind, reluctantly, submits a moment of silence, and in that unexplored, unexplainable, unearned and unjustified bliss, mind submits a tiny inspired notion: it offers the possibility of belief.
Belief arises in the absence of worldly entanglements, not because of them.
I did not write about the exceptional few.
But about the common men in the street.
They are not interested in a spiritual Journey, they cannot, and it should not been sold to them by lobbyists, that themself have no clue what they are talking about.
7 out of 8 are spiritual materialists … look that is not my idea …. it is stated by different practitioners in different schools that divide motivation in 8 catgeories.
Why should anybody be interested in the divine as such???
They are all made to live here.
These days …Vietnam…has become the place to be during the holidays.
How come?
By hearsay
By advertisement
By lobbyists
Do you think any of them had or has any interest in Vietnam.?!?!
not at all !!!
They are after what ithers SAID they got there
Oh .. by the way …nobody is to blame…it is just an ovservation
Mr tepper
Think for a moment … you might now that RK curch has many monastic orders .. that focus on spiritual practice like trappists, cartusian
One after the other monastery has to close its doors with the exception of few cartusian monastery, as the one on france.
Why … the amount of real mystic inclined is constant in any community …the rest was otherwise motivatie…they liked the monastic way of life but did not have geruïneerd divine calling
Many if the readers here were and are interested for the greater glory of themselves
Please do not get angry … it is just the opinion of an Coffee drinker .. even low quality coffee
Hi Um
Everyone has spirit and life. They couldn’t exist without it.
In the absence of social influence many recognize it. What is here doesn’t suit them anymore. So begins their journey.
Some, very few … most want a better life ..and you know that …. ask People when they pray with folded hands what they have in mind.
…
Oh lord let me know you … or … please do help me
Hi Um:
You have a model, a picture in your mind of other people, their conditions and motivation. It seems everyone here does. This is really the Church of the Human Tableaus.
I see things from my perspective, too. We are all largely in the dark. Yet, this body and brain, this time, this persona, this culture all shapes us. Yet still there are things we find turning within ourselves. Not just spiritual, but psychological. There is a psychological journey to discover ourselves, to find what capacities are within us. To see how the scars were formed, and to see the underlying self that carries them. Different layers indeed.
You had mentioned earlier that you gathered insights into folks from your past. I’d like to learn more about those actual experiences and how they shaped your perspective.
Stop flirting with Um, bro 😂
Mr. Tepper I have noting to share beyond what arises on any given moment.
And maybe the moment has come stop doing that too.
Whatever I did put on the table is not directed at you. You just go on doing what you do.
What I write are just the reactions
Your words are like stone thrown into a Pont and the ripples to are created on the pond … they are just there for a moment and then gone forever.
They have no lasting meaning
Lasting meaning?
Hm, I think that is a personal statement Um.
You are sharing your values, but in an indirect way.
We don’t experience anything without meaning, nor speak without meaning.
The problem is that we may not be fully aware of what we are saying or even why.
That speaks to my point that it’s always a good idea to be trying to find out for ourselves, why we said this or that, and what our intention was, and what we really wanted it or want it to be. These are often, generally, separate things.
We think the words we think of and say are what we are actually saying. That is rarely the case.
Anyone who has done a little introspection, and has a little humility now and then, understands the meaning and the truth behind these words.
Or not, but grains of sand, seeds do add up.
Oh Shit Spence got shot down! Daaamn! That was Brutal! Hahah 😂😂😂
“Brutal”? OMG Sucks. You have lead a very sheltered life.
Dada Spence, Relax bro, for the non-geriatric generations, the term “brutal” is just a figure of speech, commonly used when one tries to flirt or advance but gets rejected 😂 and see i was right, when i challenged you to debate about eggs it went unnoticed, because you yourself very well know its a losing argument.
What was the argument all about?
I told him that in this day and age, with eggs being considered a superfood and a top quality protein recommended by doctors, for rssb to ban eggs would be anti science and anti facts. And if course, they can never go back on their word with this because it would mean babaji was mistaken. Hence, shattering the god image 😂 no comeback. Hed rather talk about Tao to sound deep
Actually, Sucks, I asked you to take a look at the poultry industry to see the harm done to animals. But to consider harm to others as part of the decision process, with nutrition the other part, is a matter of personal ethics.
Mr Tepper.
No I am not sharing anything to anybody.
The artist loves to create.
He paints and when the paint is dry he forgets.
Those that hold on to something, move and change. Those that do not remain stable grounded in whom the are
Hi Um
The unexamined life can feel very peaceful.
Until we see the effect upon others. It isn’t a good fit for Ahimsa.
Do words spoken by a peaceful heart hateful listened to by one with a hateful ears?
Do words spoken by a hateful heart become peaceful by one with peaceful ears.
Etc.
We may live in what appears to be peace at great cost to others.
We may live in what appears to be turmoil at great benefit to the world and ourselves.
What we think and what is are two different things. We all hope they are similar.
But to be similar, for reality and our opinion to be in the same neighborhood, we have to be willing to acknowledge and accept our flaws, and then do what we can to adapt and overcome. Not to ignore, dismiss, deny, incite, hate or blame others as defense mechanisms. Those flaws bias our lens.
However, those defense mechanisms exist for a reason. When the pain or fear of reality is too great, we turn to defense mechanisms. All very natural. They have their place. But they warp our vision, they blind us.
In the brightest light we close our eyes.
But slowly, oh so slowly, we open them again, and see.
That’s what eyes are for.
The Transcendent…
https://youtu.be/LFsPIj6pmcY?is=PO7v-aqE0Ix17jOO
No amount of juggling the mind
You will never get close
There is no God
There is world of God:s
We are limited by experiences
Inception is real
As you go deeper into nameless
It again start nameforming
Multiple
Creations connected through threads
Each God having the personality of its creator
With each creator Self Withdraws
With awareness reaching
Creator of creators