How life began might be answered by science, but surely not by religion

Life, being alive, aliveness. Whatever we call it, each of us is an experiential expert about it, since we’re part of the class of living beings rather than non-living things. Of course, this assumes it is possible to tell the difference between life and non-life. That can be difficult in some instances.

Defining life has proven to be a difficult task, even though many of us can look at most things and tell if they’re alive or not. The most widely accepted scientific definition for life right now is this: “life is a self-sustaining chemical system capable of Darwinian evolution”. However, there are still problems with this definition.

For instance, viruses further blur the distinction between life and non-life since they cannot live without a living host and yet they have their own genetic material, they act as biological machines, and they evolve. As we continue to consider how life works on Earth and how we might best be able to find extraterrestrial life if it exists, we’ll continue to improve our understanding of what life really is.

The October 2026 Scientific American issue featured a section on Impossible Questions that included “How Did Life Begin?” Here’s a PDF file of the article by Sarah Scoles.
Will we ever know how life began? | Scientific American

Unsurprisingly, given my atheist frame of mind, the article made me even more confident that while science doesn’t have the answer to the question of how life began, there’s a hugely larger chance that one day science will come up with a persuasive explanation of how life on Earth came to be, than that religion will.

After all, so far all religions have been able to do is utter platitudes such as “God created the heavens and the earth, along with every living being.” Those are meaningless words, being founded in blind faith rather than clear-eyed facts.

The article presents some facts about life on Earth that should be taken into account by religious explanations of how life arose, but haven’t been, to my understanding.

As far as consensus goes: Earth’s oldest fossils date back to at least 3.4 billion years ago, with evidence that life may have arisen more than half a billion years before that. Scientists also generally agree that life didn’t come into being in a single flash but in an extended sequence. Over time chemical reactions produced early versions of metabolism, the ability for molecules to pass down information, and the formation of compartments that would become the boundaries of cells.

So if we were to assume that God exists, and that God created life on our planet, we’d have to explain why God brought forth life hundreds of millions of years after Earth was formed (our planet is about 4.5 billion years old), and why one of the earliest life forms almost certainly was a single-celled organism that, through evolution, eventually led to all other living beings, including us humans.

There are lots of religious creation myths. I’ve never come across one that explained why God or some other supernatural entity would create life that utilizes almost 4 billion years of evolution to end up with Homo sapiens creatures who can write and read blog posts about how life came to be on Earth.

At the end of the article, there’s a discussion of the search for life on other planets that includes some cogent observations about how science operates.

Still, those are huge ifs: If there’s life out there, if we know how and where to look for it, and if we find it. That’s a lot of physical and philosophical difficulty to bring together. But it’s also not impossible. “It’s always dangerous in the history of science to say that we will never know something, because later on, people have found it,” says David Dunér, a historian and philosopher of science at Lund University in Sweden.

…Maybe more evidence for the origin of life will come from a soda lake, or a planet simulator, or an actual planet far, far away. But at least some scientists are okay with the uncertainty about uncertainty. “I sometimes think about how lucky I am, in some ways, to exist in this moment of time when this still is an unanswered question, and how exciting it is to think about all the possibilities out there,” Smith says. “I think that it will be answered, but I think it will be some time because a lot of the right questions aren’t even articulated.”


Discover more from Church of the Churchless

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

17 Comments

  1. SatsangSuckz

    How Spence Teppers life began:

    It was a cold and stormy night during the late 1930s. Mr. And Mrs Tepper decided to get it on. Being hardcore rssb followers, they refused to use the standard lambskin provalactic condoms and decided to DIY a vegetarian one. It was of course ineffective, however it did block the part of the brain where all the intelligence forms. Little did they know it but they had just conceived of the worlds biggest idiot. Realizing this, their doctor recommended mommy tepper eat lots of eggs and fish so that it would be beneficial to the babys brain, but they were so kind that they refused to hurt a fish or a chicken, saying whatever would happen to their baby would be its karma, opting to take medical advice from their guru over their doctor.

    As a child, spences tale was trAgic. He was often bullied and alientated in school due to his peculiar behavior. When a teacher would ask him questions that he clearly didnt know the answer to, such as “what is gravity”, “who discovered america” or what is 3+2?” He would often give a lenghty irrelevant response, pondering about existence and philisophy, because there are no wrong answers in that department. He flunked out of school, deciding to focus on meditation over education. He soon abandoned his elderly parents in the street as they were mere attachments distracting him from what really mattered. He then turned to the only place that didnt reject him. The only place he found “love”. Rssb.

    Til today spence remains a virgin and never married for obvious reasons, not to mention his micropenis. He spends the remainder of his days behind an old computer, working full time for rssb (for free, of course) commenting, trolling and arguing on websites that offend them. He walks among us. A beacon for the uneducated. A shining light for the misinformed. A hero for all blind cult followers out there who tire of the never ending ridicule and demand respect! Bless you, spence! Radhasoami. 🙏🏼

    • Ronald

      God is an itsy bitsy organism .

    • Spence Tepper

      Wonderful, BumSux, a pleasure to read.

      I loved this part “pondering about existence and philisophy, because there are no wrong answers in that department.”

      Yes!

      My boy, you are becoming a man… I’m tearing up… Where are those tissues!

      • Spence Tepper

        Dear NoNutzSux

        There are no right or wrong answers in any department.

        Just look deeper. The whole thing is a dream, and since you dreamed it, you also invented right and wrong.

    • Spence Tepper

      Yes, SuxGotNoNutz,
      My problems began very early:
      “When a teacher would ask him questions that he clearly didnt know the answer to, such as “what is gravity”, “who discovered america” or what is 3+2?”

      I would answer each question 100% correctly! 5, Paleo-Indians, and The fundamental force that draws together matter and energy with every other object or energy in the universe!

      But sadly, in the exact wrong order and giving the answer from a different, wrong time.

      So everyone thought I was hugely mistaken. Had I only answered in the time in which I was a child! And in the order requested!

      Impossible. But entirely understandable. I had a lot more information to sort through, so I just took a “grab and Go” approach.

      Yes, indeed. This all started very young.

  2. Ron E.

    I’ve always been interested in geology, collecting and studying various rocks and fossils. What amazed me during my early studies was that crystals grow. I recall reading that certain inorganic clay minerals behaved similarly to organic organisms. So, to remind myself, I’ve just looked it up on AI, and although the hypothesis is not taken seriously, while clays are not “alive,” scientists widely accept that clay and mica surfaces played a crucial supporting role in prebiotic [live microorganisms] chemistry.

    This is Graham Cairns-Smith’s Clay Hypothesis. He proposes that the first self-replicating systems on Earth were inorganic clay crystals rather than carbon-based molecules like RNA or DNA. Introduced in 1966, this theory suggests that simple silicate minerals acted as temporary “scaffolding” that helped assemble early biological life before organic genetics replaced them.

    The idea that slate minerals—specifically phyllosilicates (clay minerals and micas)—function like living organisms is a well-known scientific theory.
    Developed most famously by chemist A. Graham Cairns-Smith in his “Clay Hypothesis,” this theory suggests that the microscopic crystal layers in clay and slate share fundamental traits with biological life and may have served as the original scaffolding for RNA and DNA.

    Still, quite interesting, I thought.

  3. Um

    The question is …
    – what is life?
    – what is change?
    – what changes?

    – how came the egg to be?
    – how came the hen to be?

    It seems that the processes in nature are everywhere the same.

    – if a seed was found, forexample in the permafrost, does anybody know how it would enfold and how it related to the rest in the past? The outcome is already there.

    So everything is born from something, it enfolds and dies. That is how it works with the apple tree, the human and the universe

    So there is direction and enfoldment in the universe from the very beginning.

    The universe acts like an apple tree

  4. Um

    Science has first to explain the existence of the LAWS of nature … the WHY!

    The consistency and how they are organicly a unity, a body.

    Why there are coffee beans and how they related to a tesla

  5. Spence Tepper

    When you see life and intelligence in all things, animate and inanimate, within and outwardly, the various forms it takes through evolution, as a flow, as a learning exercise, as an expression of a benevolent creation itself, with effort, trial and error and trying something new again and again, failing and learning a million times every second, spanning hundreds of billions of years, always accepting, always adapting without blame, without opinions, without question and always moving forward. There is so much wisdom for us to learn from reality!

    Life and intelligence are redefined the broader and deeper our view becomes.

    Therefore, we learn to respect all life, and the intelligence in it in all forms, and do our best to live without harm: To do just like life and accept, try new things, learn and move on to the next moment, ever expanding our view and our acceptance.

    Then, to see ourselves, not as unique, nor as special, except as part of this very special and awesome and progressing creation. It is natural for us to fully embrace that flow, that perusing, that transition from one moment to the next. Then indeed, because we are part of it, very special indeed.

    No two moments are ever the same. Every microsecond of the entire creation is a unique step forward.

    And we are That.

    • Spence Tepper

      What makes God perfect is their complete willingness to fail, to be wrong, to learn and to change in the blink of an eye continuously, without stopping, and thus unstoppable! That is what makes reality a supergenius… Pure acceptance and movement through it all!

  6. Um

    What humanity knows about god is nothing more than the description of the visions of some individuals.

    Not the description of god …

    It is like seeking for a perpetum mobile, or the one law that encompasses all laws of nature.

    That is beyond human mental capacities.

    Mcs was right in his answer when I asked him about something unusual that I had seen, to be true or not … did you like it? … yes … than?!

    Mystics have attributed a cause, a source to what they experienced, based upon the content of their experience …. that is … like the Bible is correct because the Bible says so.

    nothing wrong with it as I would probably do the same if I ever had to stand in their shoes

  7. Ron E.

    Fundamentally, science is in the business of investigating the ‘how’ of life and the universe. Religion is in the business of supplying the how, why, meaning and purpose. The Abrahamic religions, along with Hinduism, bring in Gods and general supernatural answers to the questions of life and creation.

    Which is why I align more with the eastern approaches such as Zen/Chan Buddhism and Taoism. There is no creator god posited in Zen/Chan (although some schools of Buddhism have devas – linked to samsara). Zen/Chan focuses on understanding the nature of suffering linked to attachment, realising the cause(s) of suffering, and awakening. Basically, psychological investigation of the mind.

    Taoism, from a philosophical perspective, has no gods and is centred on natural principles and aligning with life through harmony with Tao – the natural, unnameable flow of life and the universe. Both Zen (Chan) and Taoism align more with my experiences and outlook on life. I am quite happy that they focus on the reality of the here and now and leave the study of how the world works to the testable methods of science.

    No interest in either deism or atheism; more happy with don’t-know-ism – and life as it is.

  8. Spence Tepper

    Aristotle wrote that life arose from nothing: From trash maggots arise spontaneously.

    Some folks still believe this and are trying to prove it.

    Yet science itself proves all the time that everything has a preceding cause, and it isn’t what you think. It won’t be simpler. Science proves the opposite : it will be hugely layered and complex.

    So far, according to the Scientific American article, the folks who believe life can only arise from life have all the evidence. Yet everyone believes it will boil down to just some chemicals organizing themselves. Interesting.
    But it hardly matters because in the process of study, we learn much more about the nature of what life is really composed of. And it is awesomely elegant and complex.

    This journey of science isn’t really about proving anything. It’s about discovery and learning from reality. Every good experiment raises more questions and makes the original hypothesis and null hypothesis both way too ignorant and out of date.

    It’s the journey, the exploration, stupid! And that is fantastic! Always a mind blower. Always a dogma destroyer!

  9. yknot

    I am interested in insights or teachings from Sant Mat and Radhasoami leaders and masters regarding the theory of evolution and the origin of humanity, particularly how these concepts reconcile with the framework of the Yugas. In other words, what has anybody heard from any Master about evolution ?

    • Spence Tepper

      Ancient beliefs about creation and modern beliefs about evolution serve two entirely different functions and are distinct. But not entirely incompatible. Both support the basic idea that this creation we live in is constantly evolving, changing and progressing as a result of prior conditions. And decisions we make, actions we take.

      In the absence of information, ancient peoples created creation myths as a means to teach basic principles of cause and effect, justice, right and wrong for living today.

      Spiritual practices such as meditation have scientifically unique and verified benefits. Now that information helps encourage meditation instead of the ancient myths.

      The ancient Hindu myths refer to a physical world that is incredibly old, billions of years, with each age representing huge passages of time. Human beings existed, were dissolved and existed again repeatedly.

      There have been uncountable Brahmas, Shivas and Vishnus over untold eons of time.

      This myth helps us understand our own reality, that all things are changing, that we arrive here under very specific and different conditions that we must accept, and that we are destined to behave in certain ways. It appears to be a massive system where creation itself is a cyclical closed process and we are merely grains of sand on an infinite sea.

      Within each cycle there is more than enough room for the traditional Darwinian evolution that current science supports.

      Spirituality offers an escape from all this into eternity.

      But that escape is not to leave here and return home with this personality. It is, through the poetics and process of spiritual meditation, to shed those layers of mind and personality, in part by traversing through ever finer regions of thought into regions of pure spirit, supported by the practice of meditation.

      All that matters in Sant Mat is the practice of meditation under the guidance of a qualified master. Then we see in stages for ourselves a deeper reality.

  10. Ronald

    I can tell you that Gurinder Singh Dhillon has set back man’s spiritual evolution by hundreds of years , thousands in the nameless region. He’s like a chipmunk that squeezed through the fence of reincarnation as itself with a pea brain and a body language that says ” me me me”. And speaks volumes at the solar plexus. When a tree gets cut down it can reincarnate as a rat but when a rat gets cut down it reincarnates as a Gurinder Singh. Does that help?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *