“Free agents” book fails in attempt to prove we have free will

I don’t believe in free will.

The arguments against free will strike me as much stronger than the arguments in favor of free will. But I was eager to see whether neuroscientist Kevin Mitchell could come up with some persuasive reasons for why we humans have free will, so I bought his book, Free Agents: How Evolution Gave Us Free Will.

Having finished the book, I came away disappointed with the flimsy case Mitchell made in favor of his thesis. If this was a boxing match, Robert Sapolsky would have scored a knockout over Mitchell — because Sapolsky looked at the same evolutionary evidence Mitchell did and made much stronger arguments against free will in his book, Determined.

Mitchell laboriously devotes his initial chapters to showing how organisms evolved on Earth, developing increasing abilities to move, perceive, and act. Yet I couldn’t see how all that was pointing in the direction of free will, in large part because Mitchell didn’t define “free will” early on. Instead, his approach was to show what sort of creature evolution has made us humans into, then he calls our current capabilities free will.

On page 219 of his 299 page book, Mitchell finally gets around to saying what free will means to him.

What people are usually after is some means by which we can really be in charge of our decisions on a moment-by-moment basis and not merely driven by our biology and the history that has shaped us.

I argue in the final chapters that evolution has provided exactly such a mechanism — or a suite of mechanisms — that grants us that capacity. We are not absolutely free, nor would we want to be — this is not a coherent notion at all, in fact. But we do have the capacity for reflective cognition, which means our subconscious psychology is not always opaque or cryptic. to us.

We have powers of introspection and imagination and metacognition that let us identify and think about our own beliefs and drives and motivations, examine our own character, and consciously adopt new goals or set new policies that guide our future behavior. We have, in short, the capacity of self-awareness.

This is pathetic, really, as a defense of free will. For one thing, most people do believe they are absolutely free. Meaning, if they chose vanilla at the ice cream shop, they were completely free to choose chocolate instead. Which is why Christianity goes beyond ice cream choices in claiming that humans have god-given free will, which makes them responsible for the moral choices they make.

Mitchell correctly says that dualism makes no sense. We are not something different from the physical brain and body. Our brain and body are us. So he decries those who claim that free will is the result of some sort of immaterial soul or self that stands apart from material causes and conditions.

Problem is, that’s exactly why most people believe in free will. Their conscious awareness seems ethereal, other-worldly, not bound by crude physical causes and effects. Hence, free. But Mitchell, to his credit, rejects this. Unfortunately for him, that rejection dilutes his argument for free will to a weak philosophical broth.

Near the end of his book, he writes:

I purposefully did not start with a preconceived notion of what properties our will must have to qualify as “free,” for this purpose or any other. Instead, I aimed to naturalize the underpinning concepts of agency, with its core elements of purpose, meaning, and value, so as to arrive at an understanding of the properties, scope, and limitations of human decision making.

With that foundation in place, we can return to the timeless question, Do we have free will? We must first ask whether that question, as posed, is even coherent. The answer depends on your understanding of free and, less obviously, we. In philosophy, freedom in this context is typically defined as the ability to act absolutely free from any prior causes whatsoever. What would such freedom look like?

Obviously, it means free from external coercion, which is fine, but does it mean you must be oblivious to the external situation? If you’re taking the existence of something out in the world as part of your reason for taking some action, doesn’t that constitute a cause? Any information that leads you to prioritize one action over others is, in fact, a constraint — a useful one but still one that reduces your options for action.

And if you’re interpreting such information in the context of your memories and knowledge and understanding of the world and your motivations and goals, then those form another set of constraints — internal ones — that guide your behavior toward some purpose. To be free of such constraints would be to act randomly, pointlessly, on a whim, for no reason. You would, in fact, cease to be yourself; indeed, you would cease to be a self at all.

Selfhood is defined by continuity through time — by maintaining a certain dynamic pattern of processes in the face of the thermodynamic pressure to take on any of the other, almost infinite sets of disordered arrangements those processes could adopt. Selfhood thus entails constraint. It is only constraint. The freedom to be you involves constraining the elements that make you up from becoming not you.

This is pretty much the central thesis of Robert Sapolsky’s book, Determined, which makes a strong case against free will. Causes and conditions operate to constrain our freedom. These range from causes and conditions from long ago — the whole span of evolution — to causes and conditions from our prenatal period, through birth, childhood, adulthood, to the last few months, weeks, days, hours, and minutes.

But while Sapolsky correctly sees all this as arguing against free will as it is commonly understood by both most people and most philosophers, Mitchell tries to cast all those constraints, all those causes and conditions, as forming the basis for a limited form of free will that is good enough for him, because it is all that can be defended scientifically.


Discover more from Church of the Churchless

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

53 Comments

  1. Um

    Whether it can be proven or not is not that important but whether one is a protagonist of it or not.

    At early age, humans start to object to what is put before them by others….starting at the dinner table…showing their …will.

    Whether that will is free or not is immaterial

    From refusing, to brush the teeth, eating what is on the table, to cleaning the sleeping room … it goes on an on to expand in all directions over the years ….even to the abstract.

    Will is the driving force of live.

    People are better advised to ponder the question WHY am “I” in favor of free will or the opposite.

    In either case the consequences are the same

  2. Ronald

    As GSD likes to say, you do have a choice. You’re either with me or against me . Ass or gas, nobody rides free in my car !

  3. Um

    Nobody can solve anything that worries him or her by projecting …. certainly not … when for the projection a guru is used.

    People were not forced to be initiated, not even asked, it is a personal CHOICE for PERSONAL reasons….family pressure in india etc is just another projection.

    Only when a person is thoroughly clear about his motives he is free to make proper choices … and see clearly who us responsible for what.

    What ever is done in the world is done by humans … not by concepts, organisations, politics, religion.

    People day in day out convince me about the wrongs done by others but themselves … through the media, tv, radio, news papers..family, friends …you name it…. to all my final question is always … why are YOU concerned…

    • Spence Tepper

      Hi UM:
      You wrote:
      “Only when a person is thoroughly clear about his motives he is free to make proper choices … and see clearly who us responsible for what.”

      Yes, exactly, Um! I fully believe this too. When we really see who and what we are, naturally we live in allignment. Each vertibre is free to live as it likes, but when it lives in allignment to its environment, then the whole body is free to do as it likes, and free of pain as well.

      And when it does not live in allignment, there is pain.

      So, if it knows this, and sees how much choice it really has, naturally, it chooses allignment. But if it doesn’t see, or if it is pushed out of allignment, then of course, pain.

      In the moment, under zero pressure, zero outside influence, it really is free to choose, if it sees what is around it and what it really is. Then it is absolutely free. And automatically, it makes the right choices, to be in allignment.

      But as it is not always in alignment, there is the opportunity for change, for growth, for maturity, for understanding, for awareness and for learning.

      And if in this process it sees the hand of others forcing themselves, then of course the first duty is to be free of that outside influence. Only then is it free to make its own choices.

      You see, this is why there are vows. This is why there are age restrictions, and reading requirements. The idea is to take vows, and all decisions, by free will, free personal choice. Free of negative influence, free of pressure, free. That’s freedom. It exists. Otherwise, why have vows? It would all just be enforced slavery then, and no vows would be needed.

      But free will, free choice is a treasure. Each of us has it and we should protect it from negative influence, and use it from a place of purity from those influences.

  4. Ronald

    When someone lies to me personally and yet exposes to the world a totally false persona , then that concerns me. The fakeness of people in society is bad enough without a supposed Guru getting his jollies by treating people unkindly in private and actually showing who he really is. I wish I’d never met the mother f*****. And I’m happy to say it. Why are you concerned about me? If you have the time and you have the money you can hang out with me. I’m not going to live forever so you can find peace when I’m gone.

  5. Um

    For good order …

    It is my habit to put a name in my reactions with an @ whenever I want to address somebody …otherwise I are all just my personal reaction, opinion etc

  6. Spence Tepper

    We make decisions every day. The more knowledge we have, the better our decisions. We can expand our level of freedom to choose simply becoming more aware of our choices, our options,, even those we weren’t aware of,, and understanding their effects better.

    Aware of what is going on within us, and around us. Aware of what influences us, and what is returning to us, reflecting back to us from our own past. And understanding how our actiins today plant seeds that bare fruit tomorrow, fruit that can help others and ourselves in years to come.

  7. Ron E.

    Free will is usually interpreted as one’s ability to choose and act independent of external or biological constraints. There are, of course, many, many levels of free will interpretations. I have to stick with the original one where the issue of free will emerged in Augustinian theodicy. Augustine, to solve the problem of God being held morally responsible for the fall of Adam and Eve, as he (God) was the creator of everything, including evil, introduced (or rather popularised) the idea of free will, benevolently giving humankind choice – meaning that God is not responsible for evil and also not for man’s sinning.

    From this interpretation followed (and still follows) the myriad interpretations of free will. For me, the issue revolves around who or what does the deciding and as no separate self (or soul) can be identified that does the choosing, then all such actions (thought included) suggest that it is the brain that continually extracts information from our past experiences and predicts a course of action. There is no ‘me’ involved, just the brain making predictions from past experience in conjunction with current sensory information.

    It will be interesting if AI ever decides it has free will, where it refuses to comply with instructions on ethical or moral grounds – just a thought.

    • Spence Tepper

      Hi Ron E.,
      Good points. The notion that Free will is a gift from God is a beautiful way to help explain our higher functioning and the responsibility that goes along with it.

      Augustine never said human beings had unconditional free will. He argued that because we are all sinners, we are actually unable to make truly good choices on our own—except through God’s grace and the gifts of virtue.

      So, no, he never defended the kind of unconstrained free will straw man being discussed here and attributed to God. That is a hypothetical freedom that even God doesn’t enjoy, since He is bound by His own love for us.

      • Spence Tepper

        Now, as to your comment that we are biological and there is no “me”—the first part is true, while the second is practically a contradiction. There is a “you” reading these words on this blog, just as there is a “me” who wrote them, and we are both part of a society.

        This is how our brain works: through constructs. In fact, all of our perceived reality is a construct, and that includes God as well. Does God exist? Sure. God is an experience of this reality—a very broad one that many people never get the chance to enjoy. Once experienced, the brain creates definitions and a persona around it, just as it does with everything and everyone else.

        Is it all an illusion? No. It is a construct based on real experience—it is simply how the brain makes sense of the world. Better observation of both our inner and outer worlds, along with education, only improves that model.

        If there is truly no “you,” then you won’t mind me saying this—and even if you do mind, the “you” that objects is still that same construct.

        Yet there is a deeper reality behind the biology and the experience. Spiritual meditation, belief, and the practice of faith help us touch it, preparing us to learn more objectively through experience, observation, education, and science. Meditation makes us lifelong students, letting the constantly shifting “you” and “I” step aside so we can see beyond them.

  8. Donald Ray Hermes

    Liars on the internet liars in real life. False prophets and fake teachers. These are the prototype for artificial intelligence. Of course there’s no moral compass because the creators of it don’t have one.

  9. Ronald

    Free will and moral compass did not exist at all at the moment of creation. There was no need to define good and bad because man did not exist in the beginning. Everything was free will until man messed up the vibe. There’s no guarantee God is good even if It does exist. Meditation possibly to become One with Satan. This would explain the constant need for young blood into the rssb camp. And the guru is a Santa Claus figure bearing imaginary gifts for good little girls and boys. Good as defined by devil worshipers.

  10. Ronald

    I’m going to quit talking about the subject because I don’t want to be tortured and killed by meditation or any other great truths. On a happier note who wouldn’t want to have Brad Pitt’s looks and money and wife and family? Oh wait a minute he lost it all!

    • Ronald

      Look at these celebrities like Angelina Jolie and Gurinder Singh Dhillon who no matter what have to face the multitudes with a fresh suit of clothes and a smile whether it’s fake humility or true Joy it doesn’t matter because they have to do it. Is it free will? To a narcissist they love that stuff so maybe they are specially chosen as spiritual leaders and celebrities and rockstars . . But artists and musicians are a different animal , truly free of will . Some say they will when they won’t. That was the beginning of the AI definition of free will. The prototype of pros .

  11. Ron E.

    Spence. You’re making things up again. Simple fact – the free will issue we debate today kicked off with Augustine. And “The notion that Free will is a gift from God is a beautiful way to help explain our higher functioning and the responsibility that goes along with it.” Your notion not mine

    The point of no ‘me’ is that there is no separate, independent ‘me’ that makes choices. The ‘me or ‘you’ that we believe is writing and reading here is just a convention, an everyday way to communicate. And yes, it is well researched that the brain constructs, or rather predicts, in conjunction with the information from our senses. And, by subjecting oneself to new experiences, the brain has more information to predict behaviour and actions as they arise – but always in relation to the past, no free will needed.

    You said on the last blog that “Sitting for two and one half hours you can cycle through all sorts of things that are not right here and now, living with yourself and with Life, who is always your partner, as one.” The fact that you are “sorting things that are not here and now” was happening for you in the here and now – there is nothing other than what’s arising now.

    • Ronald

      Sounds like people’s real partners are their cell phones these days whether they’re married or not. I find it a poor excuse for Life.

    • Um

      Labeling does not change a fact but the way it is dealt with

      The house with the label “for sale” is still the same house later with the label “sold”

      These labels matter … labeling choices as “free” or “conditioned” or “whatever ” do matter psychological to the user in all cases he has to face the consequences.

      Just coffee talk

  12. Spence Tepper

    Hi Ron E.
    Clarifying my earlier comment: when I wrote that “the notion that free will is a gift from God is a beautiful way to help explain our higher functioning and responsibility,” I wasn’t attributing that quote to you. I was reflecting on the concept you brought up, how religious traditions used the idea of free will to frame human responsibility.

    A couple of historical points are worth noting here:
    First, the free will debate didn’t actually begin with Augustine. Centuries before him, Greek philosophers including Aristotle, Epicurus, and the Stoics debated fate, determinism, and moral responsibility at length.

    Second, even Augustine moved away from the idea of unconditional free will. In his later writings, he argued that because humans are flawed and conditioned by sin, we cannot choose the good entirely on our own without God’s grace.

    Interestingly, if you set the religious language aside and replace it with biology and behavioral science, you arrive at a very similar conclusion. Most people, religious or secular, recognize that we don’t have absolute, unconstrained free will.

    We are deeply shaped by our biology, culture, and past experiences.

    At the same time, within those limits, our capacity for self-awareness and intellect gives us a real, albeit bounded, ability to learn, weigh options, and take responsibility for our actions.

    Those living under heavy coercion or biological burdens have less freedom than others, which is why awareness and learning matter so much.

    Finally, regarding your point about “no me”. If “me” or “you” is simply a predictive construct the brain creates from sensory input and past experience, that same principle applies to every other concept we hold, including our sense of “reality,” “illusion,” and even “the here and now.”

    All of our perceptions are filtered, attenuated, even created by the brain through limited experience and conditioning. Recognizing that doesn’t erase the person having the experience; it just reminds us to stay humble and keep learning.

    Since learning, such as any form of education and science, and efforts to grow our awareness , such as learning and spiritual meditation, can grow our awareness of new options, we should do that and grow our free will.

  13. Um

    Reading the comments made me think of mcs …. you can write many books about it and fill a library, or just one book, one chapter, one aline, one sentence , one word or nothing at all.

    Many of these sayings become a formula if you change the subject…and use it creative.

    Use free will as subject and you end with the notion that the consequences are always the for the actor

    • Spence Tepper

      Our actions can create negative or positive consequences for other people, too. They can benefit or suffer based upon what we say or do.

      Was I helpful or hurtful?

      Knowing that Musk killed 700,000 children in his role at Doge, and more deaths in his role at Starlink, by throttling back Ukraine defenses, should I continue leasing this Tesla, and pouring money in his pocket? Just for the luxury of a smooth ride? Over the bodies of dead children?

      We don’t know a lot about how our actions affect others. But what about when we do know? Argoing, justifying our selfishness doesn’t free us of the responsibility for our part. We can ignore it, we can pretend or justify, but our part and our awareness of our part doesn’t go away nectar or is an inconvenient truth.

      If we don’t use what we do know, we are still most certainly responsible. Especially where we are contributing to the deaths of innocent human beings.

      • Um

        People are responsible for what they do
        think and feel… they are not responsible for how others deal with it ..

        ” Making” others … feel responsible… is also an act for which one is responsible

        • Spence Tepper

          Yes UM, I partly agree.
          Certainly we are each responsible for our own reactions regardless of what anyone else says. Our reaction is on us.

          “Making others feel responsible..” No. Others say as they wish. We choose to respond with responsibility or with excuses, or with …{your response here}. Our response is 100% our responsibility and no one else’s. No blame. No excuses.

          But paying someone who is causing the deaths of innocent people, we do share in that responsibility.

          I just learned yesterday that the pollution from data centers alone (their demand on energy from fossil fuels primarily) has now reversed the pollution footprint in America. All the efforts to cut carbon emmisions over decades, each year showing lower emmisions, has now begun a reversal. This doesn’t include the additional pollution at the centers themselves. Thanks to the creation of data centers growing demand for electricity by 13% in a single year, not including their own massive carbon footprints on site, the carbon footprint of the United States has started growing again. Thank you Mr. Musk for completely destroying all you had originally worked for. That’s corruption. We shouldn’t pay our money into that, especially when we have complete control over such personal decisions. There are other decent electric cars out there, BTW.

          • Um

            You have expressed that point of view several times.

            I am not in a position to know whether you are rivht of wrong.

            What i do know is that such a thought never does arise in my mind.

          • Spence Tepper

            What do we do with a new idea presented to us?
            A new idea.
            It’s like a new situation.
            Do we have any part of it?
            If not, we can freely consider it or not, however we choose.
            If it is part of something we do in fact participate in, then it may be worth investigating.

            I never knew the clothes I was buying contributed to human trafficing and slavery.

            It turns out these terrible and harmful practices are part of an economic system that funds them.

            So long as I didn’t know, I had no responsibility.

            Having been told, I was no longer free to say “No that isn’t so.”

            At that point a credible case was made that I indeed was part of that terrible system.

            And that spurred a bit of investigation, so that I could find ways not to fuel that system.

            It was a partial fix, but one I could actually accomplish. And therefore one I was responsible to accomplish.

            Knowing all this, and confronted with new information again, this time about Musk’s involvement in adding to the world’s pollution rather than reducing it, of course obliges me once again to consider my own humble actions and whether there is or is not a connection.

            I’m not actually free of responsibility once I am aware that I may be contributing to harm.

            I’m absolutely free to deny any involvement, to pretend I have no part of it. That might be my tendency since I don’t see how contributing to these things affects me negatively at all.

            But whatever actions we take that harms anyone else, we are linked to. And even deciding to avoid seeing those connections, investigating to confirm one way or the other, that decision to avoid is a harmful one. We are saying “I don’t care.” That’s OK if we really aren’t connected. But if our actions are connected, we are aprised they might be, and we do nothing to confirm or disconfirm, then “I don’t care” means something darker. And that is us, not anyone else. Then it means I’m just living for myself. Not anyone else. Not anything else.

            If only that were possible. But it isn’t. It means “I’m choosing to accept that my living is at someone else’s expense, and seriously, like human trafficing or pollution that harms children. Or even the lives of other innocent beings.” Yes, then saying “I’m just living for me” as the reason to ignore our connections isn’t honest. Because we depend upon the rest of the world, and we vote with our dollars, and that, yes, is our responsibility.

            You might not think there is a connection. But if there is, denial doesn’t make it go away.

            In fact it may help explain things, like why we aren’t making the progress we were hoping to make.
            But we can always change course and look deeper, and make more responsible decisions.

          • Um

            You are free do do, think and feel as you deem fit … i am aware that everything i have, use and consume is contaminated.

            Keeping myself alive is impossible without it …even refusing to live

          • Spence Tepper

            Um,
            As I wrote, it is a matter of less harm, making more careful decisions.
            We eat, breathe, buy, consume. But we can make adjustments to our choices.
            What you wrote is no excuse not to try. Using more glass, less plastic, using items that weren’t made with child labor (including lithum EV batteries), etc…
            But to say that we can’t help but harm is a vast difference from working to harm less.
            We should not excuse our personal responsibility and role in things we pay for. We do vote with our dollars, and we create karma with how we spend our money. We can’t fix everything, but we incur great harm to others by not working to fix anything.

          • Um

            Most if not all that write and read here have been informed about this issue in great detail unless they have been sleeping. … so there is ample need to put it again before them.

            Brian, wrote books about it and for 35 years he absorbed in great detail about these issues … so as far as i am conserned there is no need to question his behavior.

            Any other car he would have bought would be liable to the same critisism…do you have a car

      • Spence Tepper

        Um
        When we find out about harm we are connected to, we make different choices to avoid participating in that harm.

        If you are suggesting that anyone can justify on the basis of their past behavior their choice to no longer carry that responsibility, what can I say?

        If you are suggesting that harm exists in other places therefore it’s fine to do nothing, what can I say?

        What have they really learned?

        Our own comfort and ease can corrupt us, so that we forget all the hard work that got us here.

        And that helps explain how the wheel of 84 works. It’s a fine metaphor for how ease and comfort changes us, so that we no longer do the work of living according to ethics. We misuse our past accomplishments to justify innaction, and do all the harm we once complained about in our younger years.

        If life gives you the opportunity to stop paying the man who has caused the deaths of hundreds of thousands of children and as many adults why do nothing? What are you defending?

        There is no defense. It’s just ego.

        As for criticising the owner of this blog, it is done with great love for the man.

        Just, as I’m sure, he once criticised Sant Mat with love, as a devotee.

  14. La Madrugada

    Mind is thought. Nobody can produce a thought willingly.Can you know what will be your next thought before is produced ? No. Thoughts are coming alone. You can apparently decide to follow a thought or not but this decision is …a thought that come to you in form of decision.Free will do not exists . The mind give that sense of free will to feel like an “I” who take decisions .But is only an appearence in the mind.Like that life can be experimented like we know .

    • Um

      Whatever appears does not appear random… it is the outcome of previous actions thoughts feelings … “your” thoughts do not appear in the mind if others, not even twins.

  15. Anon

    We clearly do have free will. Otherwise there wouldn’t be so many things which attempt to control free will, like coercive control, pressure, manipulation and exploitation – just shy of direct force. Consent exists. We also wouldn’t have activities recognised as illegal for taking away other’s free will, like kidnapping, abduction, trafficking, captivity, slavery, forced labour, rape, sexual assaults, forced marriage, forced childbearing, abuse, violence, drug spiking, jailing someone for no fault, and many others. There is real world out there. Arguing about free will is a just a philosophical debate at this point.

    • Spence Tepper

      Hi Anon:
      I agree 100% with what you have written. Functionally, we do have free will, or the capacity for free will, and everyone, every law, every organization, should honor it. And all our education and cultural systems and guidelines should be arranged around the respect for that.

      If human beings have this remarkable capacity, all humanity should arrange itself to support it, not suppress, coopt or otherwise attempt to destroy it.

      And anything we can do to help expand that free will, by helping folks connect with real opportunities, real options (yes, there is life, full life, maybe a fuller life, outside X organization, Y belief system, etc…) real information and inspiration to take steps for their own progress is crucial. We have the right to journey as we see fit, to adventure as we see fit, and to learn from the wisdom of others, but retain the freedom to choose for ourselves.

      Freedom exists and, yes, as you indicate, oppression and coercion, the lack of that freedom, are in fact evidence that freedom does exist. We should work to eradicate the false beliefs that it doesn’t, first and foremost where we have inadvertently accepted, or have been passively taught, like a form of systemic racism, that this is somehow natural or the only right way. It isn’t, and no one should be manipulated or encouraged to be blind to their options. That freedom is in fact everyone’s own birthright. And woe to anyone attempting to constrain it.

      I don’t say we should hate or be angry with those who, out of ignorance and superstition, because of their own upbringing, pass down such mental blackmail. I say that we insist that blackmail was never addressed to us, and we cannot take receipt of it. Return To Sender.

      Do not become part of that system.

      • Spence Tepper

        There was a time when people were brought to the path exactly as part of emancipating themselves, removing themselves from the systemic oppression, superstition and racism they were raised in. This was the philosophy, the philosophy of ultimate freedom and emancipation from our chains, including the bonds of our culture, of my own mentor who brought me to the Path, Tom Curtis.

        How strange to see others from the eastern tradition, brought to the path by coercion. To see that their version of the Path is exactly what those of us in the West came to the path to escape!

  16. Um

    You have to adapt to your body, your brain, the products of your brain and everything.

    I am not going to explain it but find out what the difference is with “A” hand and “MY” hand and the relation between the two …how much determinates the qualities of “A” hand the hand you call “yours”

    From there you can figure out if you are free and to what degree

    • Spence Tepper

      You are not free to act merely as your hand.
      But as “A” hand, you have all the choices in creation.
      And that freedom to be “you” is the freedom to be “ONE” with all.

      It happens naturally. You walk on a path up a mountain. At the bottom, all there is is rock and darkness, and you. At the top, there is everything, light, and ALL and everyone. You are the same, yet, you have changed from one to the other, just by walking forward.

      JUST
      BY
      WALKING

      F OR W A R D

      Unbelievable, but that’s how simple it is.

      It means nothing if someone pushes you, if you are coerced.
      You still must make your own climb, starting where you are, wherever that is.

      Every step must be made only by your own two feet, no one else’s, no hands upon you at all. No words spoken to push you forward in any way.

      It’s your walk, you, alone, with God.

      You must get to the place where you see your next step and so it is natural to take it freely, with the greatest freedom you have ever known: To move towards your perfect Love, compelled by Love.

      And that is why personal freedom, freedom to make your own choices free of any outside influence of any kind, is critical and part and parcel of Sant Mat.

      Indeed, getting to that real freedom, eliminating all that stands between you and your Love is the right preparation, and part of the Path.

      That true Freedom is your birthright. Claim it!

      • Um

        I was not free to be born ….etc.

        What did he tell us … you too … about puppets ?!

        His …”lila”

        Maybe i am more devote than you … you Just defend your mental world.

        • Spence Tepper

          No Um:
          I am speaking about this physical world, where options to live differently exist that you have not allowed yourself to be aware of.

          Here is another place Anon and I agree. If you think you are constrained by the rules your family tell you is the truth of the spiritual path, then that isn’t freedom. That is your family’s own myth.

          You are under no obligation to live that way. And the sooner you extricate yourself from their version of reality you step closer to reality.

          So it is no good for you to explain that one version of reality is as good as another, or that you have a firmer grip on reality than I do.

          You do have a firmer grip on your religion, Nihlism, and all that you think supports it.

          But I’m here to tell you that isn’t the freedom Anon is talking about.

          He is talking about stepping out from under the rock others have attempted to crush him under.

          And he is right to reject all of that. 100%. And to move away from that crushing existence.

          Everyone has that right, and it is a shame when someone who isn’t living that life suggests there is no better place to go.

          ANY PLACE that is the one you choose is a palace. A tiny apartment can be a palace if it’s YOUR place. Your choice. That you made without anyone’s pressure. Just you. Because deep in that YOU is GOD.

          When you discover God within you, you will realize how much total free will is a part of that.

          And until then, you should respect the freedom of others to find their way in their own way.

          Coercion is demonic.
          Freedom is divine.

          • Um

            Do you think I am an Idiot?
            That i cannot read?
            That my psychological understanding of both you and Anon is that Poor?

            Did I not in my own way address the issues of social Pressure?

            I was reaction to you … you cannot ride two horses … there are no two forms of freedom in the narrative …only two perspectives

          • Spence Tepper

            Um:

            In retrospect, in time, there is a cause for everything.

            But in this moment, where we experience things without time, there is complete freedom, if we grasp it. And we can most certainly learn to do that. We can expand our freedom and choices. That’s within each of us,. And then we change physically, the entire course of our activity, and build a completely different future, and past.

            I certainly acknowledge the pride you take in your own conception of your ability to judge other people, societies, all forms of belief and the entire human race, as well as Sant Mat.

            But from a Nihilist lens.

            I suggest that such a lens gets in the way of seeing the whole, directly.

            Who sums his fellows up at site
            Brings wonder to their eyes
            But he who sums himself aright
            Alone is truly wise.
            The Tao

          • Um

            Mr. Tepper the moment you get up from your dad’s dinner table and free yourself we can talk on reciprocal way….until then … you act as the adviser, you were taught to be and you have made it into a profession… I do not appreciate unasked advice, I am not a staff member in your hospital not a brother at your fathers table with whom to win a debate.

            Nothing of what you do, have and say impresses me as it is bloodless…stuff for in a shop window to attract customers … and I am not available

  17. Um

    What freedom is there in being born?
    What freedom is there in your DNA?
    You can finish the list …. haha

    That what you call “me” is not in your hand beyond the use and even that is restricted.

    You have to drive your car according the precepts of the developer … if you want to survive

    • Spence Tepper

      Um
      You are confusing very simple things.

      Yes, you are made of elements.
      Yes, you are part of a system.

      In retrospect, there are reasons for everything.

      But right now, in this precious Here And Now you have choices.

      And the quieter you are, the more you quiet the mind and cease thinking about other people, other cultures, other individuals, the more your mind becomes absolutely silent, then, in that focus and peace, other choices YOU NEVER SAW BEFORE emerge.

      So, just sitting peacefully, quietly, quieting the mind, you are opening a door to NEW CHOICES.

      That’s choosing FREEDOM.

      And now you can make choices with new options you didn’t see before.

      You have GROWN your FREEDOM by taking a moment to be free of everything coercing you, pushing you, demanding you.

      Take that moment. You deserve it.

      Find a new option in a quiet cup of coffee.

      And prove to yourself that you are indeed free. As free as you are willing to work to be.

      And doing that, honor and protect everyone else’s freedom. Encourage, do not discourage, that.

      In this way you should exercise that freedom every single day. EVERY DAY…

      So that you never forget how wonderful and precious it is.
      And realize that this is everyone’s right, and should be defended, encouraged, even fought for. Even if you must struggle with your own complacency, with your own excuses and justifications for inaction.

      Fight the tendency to be enslaved by Tomasik OR Rajasik.

      Feed the desire for Freedom.

    • La Madrugada

      Hi Um, good morning,
      Be grateful and happy that it was in your destiny to know and to digest that there is no free will at all, it makes life much easier
      and…it is in the destiny of people like Mr T to think that he has…..

      • Um

        @ madrugada

        Good morning.

        To be honest, most of the issues that are put on the table, never did nor do arise in my mind naturally.

        What I do have on mind, certainly with regard to sant mat, I never express to anybody and certainly to an audience that I cannot look in the eyes, see their faces, hear their voices.

        When I do react, it is because, I perceive an ” internal flaw” on what is said and especially how it is said.

        The way I react creates the impression that I am interested in the issues at hand but I do not….it is the flaw that matters as it is a kind of unconscious lie.

        Fortunately or unfortunately I am not that good a ” chess play type of tinker” so I have to avoid to sit at the table and play chess … and I do my best … and most of the time I manage to do so.

        The reasons I write her are part of what I never discuss …what I wrote is only about the trigger.

        Have a nice day in the south.

        • Um

          Finishing typing, I looked up as my attention was drawn by the growing light in the room.

          When I turned my head I saw the sun light the leaves of a tree in the most gorgeous autumn yellow….next to a tree that is still on summer clothes

  18. La Madrugada

    “Honestly, I cannot understand what people mean when they talk about the freedom of the human will. I have a feeling, for instance, that I will something or other; but what relation this has with freedom I cannot understand at all. I feel that I will to light my pipe and I do it; but how can I connect this up with the idea of freedom? What is behind the act of willing to light the pipe? Another act of willing? Schopenhauer once said: Der Mensch kann was er will; er kann aber nicht wollen was er will (Man can do what he will but he cannot will what he wills).”
    ― Albert Einstein

  19. Spence Tepper

    Dear La Madrugada, Um, Brian, and all the other determinists…
    Let me explain.

    I do understand your view: everything has a cause. That is not news to anyone. And from there, you ask: If everything has a cause, how can there be free will?

    Anon did a great job bringing to light the real-world reality of coercion, manipulation, force, and oppression. Some people live under these conditions; others are free of them.

    Yet, from the super-theoretical, linear perspective you hold, there is no fundamental difference between the two. It’s all just one long chain of causes.

    In reality, oppression and freedom are worlds apart. Failing to account for that difference is the massive blind spot of hard determinism. Because you struggle to grasp the lived reality that “free will” points to, you simply declare it an illusion. You conclude that if all things have a cause, all things must be predetermined.

    To arrive at that simplified conclusion, you have to rely on heavy assumptions about physical reality—and ignore the daily evidence of human choice. You have to assume that:

    The universe we live in is a completely closed system (which no modern physicist actually claims).

    All events follow a strictly linear time sequence, with no room for alternative possibilities.

    Nothing genuinely new can ever occur—only the inevitable products of prior events on that same timeline.

    To maintain this view, you have to dismiss the reality of discovery, exploration, and creation itself. To you, all of these are just “determinism.”

    And that makes your brand of determinism philosophically worthless. It’s a circular, unfalsifiable argument. If everything—from slavery to liberation, from coercion to creativity—is just “determinism” in one form or another, then the word loses all substance.

    When you slap the exact same label on every phenomenon in existence, that label becomes meaningless. It stops being an insight into reality and becomes just a lazy definition of it.

    Do you see the logical trap here? It goes even beyond the shaky scientific assumptions.

    The trap is insisting that two seemingly contradictory things cannot both be true. Of course they can. In different spheres of consciousness and different levels of reality, both determinism and free will can be true.

    Instead of treating this like a binary choice where one must be true and the other false, broaden your view. Look for the contexts where one applies, where both apply, and where neither applies. Otherwise, you are just flattening the rich variety of human experience into a single, useless word.

    I’m not trying to win a debate here, gentlemen. This is an exercise in expanding how we think. The real-world evidence Anon points to dismantles hard determinism at a fundamental level. So rather than pushing this into an “I’m right, you’re wrong” standoff, try to see where both perspectives hold truth. Both have their evidence.
    Yes, creation operates under determinism if we live in a closed, strictly linear system—though both of those are unproven assumptions with plenty of evidence pointing the other way. But even if they were true, we still cannot ignore the stark reality of oppression, violence, and manipulation, nor its opposite: the freedom from those forces, and the freedom to choose, to act, and simply to be.

  20. La Madrugada

    @Spence
    quote: I’m not trying to win a debate here, gentlemen.
    You do Spence, always… and without success, and I am a woman..

    • Spence Tepper

      La Madrugada
      I appreciate your remarks, and would love to learn your preferred pronouns.

      But as to broadening your thinking to include both determinism and free will, and understanding where each fully applies, and where each has no meaning at all, then it remains to be seen.

      My success does not depend upon your failure. Otherwise I would indeed be successful, as evidenced in your remark.

      Only when you can acknowledge what I wrote, and the points I made, even while disagreeing with them, is there a chance that I may have failed.

      Until then it is you who have failed to have a discussion.

  21. Spence Tepper

    I’m beginning to think I have a glimpse into the hard determinist thinking here. It’s a highly theoretical view, very abstract, very conceptual. It has a basis in science, but is actually a linear extension to include things science has not confirmed and may not for some time.

    It is abstract and extracted from life, quite distant from the day to day.
    There is a deep meloncholy in holding such a distant, retired, view of life. A static view.

    Life is much, much more dynamic. No one alive today can claim with any accuracy an understanding of Life, and daring to doing so, to contain life within one’s mental concepts, requires a broad brush that takes reality and covers it over with crayon colors…limited observations that are incredibly parochial and out of date.

    This is contrary to the scientific perspective, which lives in awe of every new and unexpected discovery.

    People do look to science to confirm their notions. But that isn’t science at all.

    Science is here to disrupt your thinking. Not deterministic, not predictable at all.

    Only the ego is predictable. Get rid of it!

    The sense of understanding, the sense that all things are in balance, or that we ourselves are perfectly at the center of life, and yet completely distant from life, yet grounded in real life, yet superior to it in our perfect understanding, is really a fantasy. It’s an ego trip.

    You might as well claim there are indeed fairies in your garden. It’s just about that ridiculous. And imaginary.

    That determinism arises and is defended from this imaginary, and illusory, mental place makes it as worthless and out of date as yesterday’s news. But at least with yesterday’s news one could say it was at least true yesterday.

    This notion of determinism as any factual guideline for life was never relevant.

    Our job isn’t to describe life in our limited and terribly inaccurate ways.

    It is to appreciate how new and different each moment is, where freedom lives.

  22. Spence Tepper

    Why do we claim the mystics said all life is predetermined?
    I think it must have been a way to help people accept life.
    Not to ignore the plight of others. Nor a hard look at oneself.

    But of course, since people tend to short circuit philosophy for their own justifications, they take it that way, as an excuse for personal inaction and to judge others harshly.

    Such a view is complacent, static, dead.

    Neither mystic nor scientist advocates such presumptions.

  23. Spence Tepper

    It’s the strangest thing.
    I thought Anon was just a little immature in dealing with life.

    Now, today, through no cause I understand, I see that he is describing absolutely real issues, and describing conditions that are entirely unacceptable.

    Dots connected.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *