Information is the key to everything, including religions

I’m a big fan of Yuval Noah Harari, the Israeli historian who has written Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow, and 21 Lessons for the 21st Century. I’ve read and enjoyed all three books.

But until a friend told me in an email how much he’s liking Harari’s Nexus: A Brief History of Information Networks from the Stone Age to AI, I hadn’t realized that I’d missed this 2024 book. Which I ordered right away from Amazon. (Note: the book is 407 pages long, which I guess is brief for a historian.)

Wow. I read the Prologue this morning, and that alone confirmed my already strong belief that Harari is one of the most creative non-fiction authors I’ve ever come across. And I’ve come across a lot of them. Plus, Harari is such a skilled writer, his ideas flow along so pleasingly smoothly, the pages fly by without the mental strain I often feel when reading other books about complex topics.

On the first page, Harari poses an important question. Here’s how the book starts out.

We have named our species Homo sapiens — the wise human. But it is debatable how well we have lived up to the name. Over the last 100,000 years, we Sapiens have certainly accumulated enormous power. Just listing all our discoveries, inventions, and conquests would fill volumes. But power isn’t wisdom, and after 100,000 years of discoveries, inventions, and conquests humanity has pushed itself into an existential crisis.

We are on the verge of ecological collapse, caused by the misuse of our own power. We are also busy creating new technologies like artificial intelligence (AI) that have the potential to escape our control and enslave or annihilate us. Yet instead of our species uniting to deal with these existential challenges, international tensions are rising, global cooperation is becoming more difficult, countries are stockpiling doomsday weapons, and a new world war does not seem impossible.

If we Sapiens are so wise, why are we so self-destructive?

Harari then talks about fables and myths of many traditions that believe we humans have some fatal flaw in our nature that tempts us to pursue powers we often don’t know how to handle. I wasn’t aware that Goethe published such a tale called “The Sorcerer’s Apprentice.” I just recall the Disney animation of the same name that showed the disastrous result of a young apprentice who used a sorcerer’s spell to enchant a broom to fetch water for him. So much water ends up being fetched, this threatens to flood the workshop. Harari writes:

What do the cautionary fables of the apprentice and of Phaethon tell us in the twenty-first century? We humans have obviously refused to heed their warnings. We have already driven the earth’s climate out of balance and have summoned billions of enchanted brooms, drones, chatbots, and other algorithmic spirits that may escape our control and unleash a flood of unintended consequences.

What should we do, then? The fables offer no answers, other than to wait for some god or sorcerer to save us. This, of course, is an extremely dangerous message. It encourages people to abdicate responsibility and put their faith in gods and sorcerers instead. Even worse, it fails to appreciate that gods and sorcerers are themselves a human invention — just like chariots, brooms, and algorithms.

The tendency to create powerful things with unintended consequences started not with the invention of the steam engine or AI but with the invention of religion. Prophets and theologians have summoned powerful spirits that were supposed to bring love and joy but occasionally ended up flooding the world with blood.

Religions are one form of totalitarianism, which aims at controlling information in order to keep power in the hands of a ruler or cabal of people. This is why Trump, a would-be authoritarian who makes no secret of his love of tyrants like the rulers of Russia and China, continually refers to “fake news”, his term for any news that doesn’t put him in a good light.

This also explains why Radha Soami Satsang Beas, the religious organization headquartered in India and led by a guru that I belonged to for 35 years, got upset when I started this blog in 2004 and starting writing about subjects that normally weren’t talked about in public. I spoke about this in a 2005 post, “I’ve been fired.”

Well, my Meister Eckhart fantasy has been fulfilled. I’ve been fired from giving talks (known as “satsangs”) at meetings of my spiritual group because my Church of the Churchless writings have been too heretical.

Yesterday our local secretary informed me that he had been told by a regional representative, Vince Savarese, that my blogging about Radha Soami Satsang Beas (RSSB) had caused a lot of people to be uncomfortable. In New York. In India. All around the RSSB world.

Naturally I blurted out “Wow, that’s great! People are reading my blog!” It didn’t bother me to hear that I’ve been making some people uncomfortable. I regularly hear from others that they appreciate my posts, so it all evens out. Yin and yang. Like and dislike. Attraction and repulsion. That’s the way of the world.

Regardless, the RSSB powers that be don’t want me to be a speaker anymore. I said, “That’s fine. Now the folks at the Radhasoami studies discussion group who have been taking bets that I wouldn’t last as a speaker beyond mid-2006 will feel vindicated.”

I’ll end this introduction to Harari’s book — more posts about it surely will be coming — with what Harari says about those who espouse religiosity over science.

An alternative populist solution is to abandon the modern scientific idea of finding the truth via “research” and instead go back to relying on divine revelation or mysticism. Traditional religions like Christianity, Islam, and Hinduism have typically characterized humans as untrustworthy power-hungry creatures who can access the truth only thanks to the intervention of a divine intelligence.

In the 2010s and early 2020s populist parties from Brazil to Turkey and from the United States to India have aligned themselves with such traditional religions. They have expressed radical doubt about modern institutions while declaring complete faith in ancient scriptures. The populist claim that the articles you read in The New York Times or in Science are just an elitist ploy to gain power, but what you read in the Bible, the Quran, or the Vedas is absolute truth.

Me, I’ll stick with the New York Times and my science magazines.


Discover more from Church of the Churchless

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

38 Comments

  1. Ron E.

    It’s been said that those who control the media control the mind, whether that media is TV, Radio, newspapers, or the many religious and spiritual printed texts. Small wonder, and it is obvious why Trump demonises the media that disagrees with him and tries to control the public mind through his ‘Truth Social’ ravings. And yes, this includes his constant lies and misinformation that climate change is a myth and disparaging wind and solar power.

    But it is difficult for us humans being brought up on a constant diet of myths taken for truth. I guess the problem is that we identify with much of the information we are fed, which gradually becomes a part of our identity, a self that we vigorously defend and maintain – sometimes even to death.

    It’s often pointed out that our sense of who/what we are is bound up with our beliefs, our hopes, and our desires, all contributing to a constructed self. Although not real in the physical sense, it feels real mentally, and it is through this information-created self that we mostly live and exist.

    Some of this information may be true and valid, but one heck of a lot of it is that which panders to our hopes, desires, and fantasies, which all go toward forming a constructed self. Any information that helps maintain our self-story is welcomed, but that which contradicts it is rejected. We are regularly engaged in looking for confirmation of our beliefs and undermining, in some way, those that appear to expose our adopted false sense of self.

  2. Ronald

    When I first discovered RSSB Maharaji , in this life and that’s important, I was already following all of the vows except for being too young to be given the mantra. So in a way rssb started following me and I didn’t fall in love with the master, he fell in love with me , and later admitted it ! This current Guru doesn’t know what love is and he’s still looking so he’s been put on a grading curve just to be called Guru.
    I like that writer that you’re reading , from your brief description. He has the same opinion about mankind as I do and why in the world would anyone desire interaction with them much less teaching them ? Only a dumb waiter in Spain and a over educated fool would want to be Guru.
    And together like Hansel and Gretel they are dropping bread crumbs and pigeon shit along the path for the ecological modern new age yuppie to pick up on. It gives them an excuse to be together but I’m more concerned about me. Me and my hip movement.

    • Ronald

      It’s those videos that his followers make on YouTube that make me dislike him more and the things I say here are just making his followers love him even more. So when I get left in his last will and testament all’s well that ends well.

  3. Spence Tepper

    Hi Brian:

    You wrote:
    “Yesterday our local secretary informed me that he had been told by a regional representative, Vince Savarese, that my blogging about Radha Soami Satsang Beas (RSSB) had caused a lot of people to be uncomfortable. In New York. In India. All around the RSSB world.”

    “Naturally I blurted out “Wow, that’s great! People are reading my blog!” It didn’t bother me to hear that I’ve been making some people uncomfortable. I regularly hear from others that they appreciate my posts, so it all evens out. Yin and yang. Like and dislike. Attraction and repulsion. That’s the way of the world.

    “Regardless, the RSSB powers that be don’t want me to be a speaker anymore. I said, “That’s fine. Now the folks at the Radhasoami studies discussion group who have been taking bets that I wouldn’t last as a speaker beyond mid-2006 will feel vindicated.”

    When you work for any organization, it is expected that you will promote that organization, not question it publicly. So, when that, or any organization decides you should no longer be representing it internally to others seeking inspiration, this is just gravity taking hold. It isn’t personal, and while you claim it doesn’t bother you, I see it does.

    You should not blame an organization for making decisions that retain 100% internal support for its own policies and position.

    Every employee who signs away their rights with NDAs and Confidentiality Agreements realizes they have given up their rights to complain, their voice. And when they decide later they wish to have and use that voice, for reasons important to them, then, after confirming that they cannot live within those guidelines, they find a place for themselves elsewhere.

    In every organization, every club, every religion, every team, every business, every service, the dynamics are the same. If you cannot function with full support for the agreed system, and your efforts to make something like constructive change cross those boundaries repeatedly, then it’s fair to say the organization isn’t for you. Or that the organization is fine, it’s just people, but the role as publicly representing the organization isn’t for you anymore.

    Clearly you were already moving in a different direction. There is no need to blame Sant Mat or RSSB for your personal journey. It’s not a bad journey. You can thank them for helping you take those steps which you must take to be honest with yourself.

    It was different for me. For me to be honest with myself, the Path is my destination. It’s going to be different for different people. I never mistook the organization for the Master or the Path. I was brought in by a mentor, Tom Curtis, who, before I even asked for initiation, made the distinction between organization, which was just filled with people dealing with their own flaws, and the Path.

    Tommy said to me very early that even the Master confided in him that there were wonderful people not on the path, and some that were on the path were quite insufferable.

    You can fail at the organization and succeed beautifully in your own inner work with your Master…

    Or you can go anywhere you like, as you have.

    There is never any need for blame.

    The entire past, what felt good and what hurt, brought you here to where and who you are today. They are all to be thanked. Because you have become something very special. In spite of your claiming otherwise.

    Kits rise against the wind, not with it. A little adversity helps align us to what deep inside is really important.

    Thank everyone, be happy you are where you are today.

    Before I even asked for initiation, Tommy inoculated me, “Look Spence, there are guns at the Dera…Yah. Sevadars are wearing Guns, because there are people who will take advantage of you everywhere. So don’t let your guard down just because someone says they are initiated. They are going through their Karmas just like everyone else. That isn’t the Path. The Path is just you and Master. And one day it won’t even be you. It will just be Master for you.”

    • Um

      The narrative of this path speaks of “sheep” … owned sheep’s….that are brought to the stable by a “shepherd” … a shepherd that uses his dogs to drive them forward

      Where is the freedom you agreed with Anon.

      What freedom is there in words like master and slave?

      Psychological i do understand that mechanism of total surrender you point at in the last sentence….many books have been written about it to explore this interhuman power exchange

      Think!

      • Spence Tepper

        Um
        This shephard uses no dog. Merely his whistle.

        Sheep run happily to their beloved Shephard!

        It is love. Love is what our freedom allows us to pursue.
        So we give ourselves to the object of our love, freely.

        It is exactly the opposite of coercion.

        From a retrospective look at all the forces that have moved us, it is inevitable.
        But when at every juncture those choices are ours, freely made, not as compromises, not at anyone else’s encouragement, or by anyone else’s pressure, but directly choosing the perfection we see before us, then that is freedom. When the distance between us is our pain, and the closer we get the happier we are, that is freedom.

        And the more we make such choices, the closer to our hearts desire we grow, we are liberated.

        When you become One with your beloved, who is in control?

        Haven’t you simply liberated yourself by becoming one with the object of your love?

        And hasn’t your divine Lover finally found their peace in you?

        You can’t say anymore “the Master controlled me”…That was never the case. You cannot say you and he are any different at all. You chose freely. Just as He did.

        Kabir wrote:
        When I knock upon the Lord’s door, and He asks of me “Who is there?”
        All I can say is “It’s YOU.”

    • Ronald Dumbest

      You don’t think Brian knows what he wrote? You’re a bad reflection on that institution Tepper and I don’t want you anywhere near mine.

  4. Um

    I would advise you to listen to some q@a sessions with mcs were he elaborates this parable

    • Um

      Find his parable of enlisting in the French foreign legion.

      Find his parable on tractors.

      Find his is references of Christ’s responsibility losing a sheep he was ordered to bring to the owner.

      Find his interpretation of the tale of the lost son.

      Talk to those that have approached him of being released of the contract …. the answer is … you cannot unilateral end the contract. I am bound to the owner too and you have to be brought home whether you like it or not.

      Mr. You cannot feed met stories .. I have not been there closed ears

      • Spence Tepper

        Um:

        He said exactly as I cited. The Sheep hear His call.
        You have heard what you wanted to, and now quite sadly, are trying to use Master as a skirt to hide behind.

        Make your own decisions, Um.
        If you are on the path, you may have some credibility in using Maharaji’s name. But as a nihlist who isn’t absolutely devoted to his practice, the result of your using his name is not a fair reflection of His teachings nor the path.

        When we choose Freedom, we grow it.
        If we do not choose freedom, but whatever we are addicted to, then of course, gravity takes hold, the laws of this physical and psychological existence push us to pay attention, just like an illness or disease.

        But if we are free to acknowledge that, then we can adjust accordingly.

        The point of life however, is not to move when we are pushed, but to live in such alignment to our circumstances that we are free to do pretty much as we like. Truly free.

        You see there is the Path within you.
        And there is the organization of RSSB and your relationship to that organization and / or its people.

        Rather than broad brush the whole place, which only diffuses your ability to act freely, you may look at your own personal choices, compare them, if you wish, to what you promised Maharaji, and let yourself consider more deeply why, how, and what to do next.

        Let yourself consider things you never considered or allowed yourself to consider before.

        That can’t be done here on a blog. It’s too intimate. It’s just between you and Maharaji.

        Quiet the mind, focus on your own situation, and then let some other ideas emerge from that incredible mystery. Whatever truth you will ever learn is in there. But you must choose to start learning again, not explaining the same stuff over and over. You are ready to become free if you choose to become a better student.

        Now, as for Anon, he has described crushing emotional and psychological abuse. He needs to flee from that and find a place of peace he can continue in his own way.

        You know as well as I do that Maharaji, Baba Ji, all the Saints say that the Truth, that GOD is within each of us and our duty is to pursue Him within. Then we discover the nature of reality and God, and of course they can’t be put into words very well.

        But for that to take place, we need to have an atmosphere of total freedom, no coercion, no pressure. Zero, Zip.

        Once you build that, don’t waste it judging the world. That’s a poor use of your freedom.

        Learn, and dig deeper within. Then you grow your freedom.

        So simple, Um.

        Find the balance and the true inner peace to really understand what Maharaji was talking about. You are confused. He can help you, but you must meet Him in that place.

  5. Um

    Just listen to old tapes …. do your own research and see who is here hiding what behind a skirt.

    And others that have sit there for decades can come forward and tell whether they agree with either of us … even Brian can … haha.

    You have something to lose here … something that has nothing to do with santmat … it is an psychological issue an you are fighting for it.

    You are not at home Mr. Tepper … this is a table in an internet saloon and not your dads dinner table.

    • Spence Tepper

      Look Um

      What do you gain by claiming there is no hope?

      The answer will explain a lot.

    • Spence Tepper

      Um
      The elephant in the room is Shabd and belief in Shabd.

      You can go on forever about your interpretation of what Maharaji said, reaching out for support to others.

      But you are distant from Maharaji’s core teaching of Nam, the holy spirit, and that distance creates a limited and flawed view of his teachings.

      That you double down on your own interpretation speaks to ego and mind.

      Unlike you I don’t need to insist I’m right. I’m wrong every day, Um. It is only Shabd that is an absolute, a lighthouse, a massive cathedral bell that is the only thing consistent in my understanding.

      Tomorrow I may see Maharaji’s teachings in a new light. Happens all the time. It’s inevitable.

      But you have taken my seat at the table, insisting your opinion is truth.

      That was never my issue.

      Opinions are never truth. That is a different level of awareness altogether, beyond mind.

    • Ronald

      Um you understand Spence. He has no faith in you or anybody else, he just has hope. He’s one of the few men I’ve ever noticed that has a period every month. I don’t know why you keep feeding his wild imagination . He:s like the class clown who’s not funny because he’s so serious about something that he calls his guru. And he’s jealous of people like me and you. You can’t give respect or be nice to a narcissist because of this is what happens. Just ask anyone on this blog about Spence the fence.

      • Um

        @ Ronald

        The very moment I know why I go on and on, have myself triggered, I would jump in the air from joy and relief.

        Faced with flaws in somebody’s behavior I become uneasy and that is not comfortable.

        Flaws does not mean that a person has to be perfect it has something to do with NOT acting etc as expected

        You do not want walking in the forest that a bolder all of sudden speaks to you .. that would be a flaw.

        But I have made some steps … unexpected noises do not longer alarm me … and allow my system to process the information…nor does what people say triggers my anger.

        I must be honest sometimes I remember with nostalgia the days that anger would rage in me like storm, controlling the raw energy as sailing a ship on a storm… haha …. vaguely I remember to have heard that the guru does so after initiation …if he did it was a piece of art…I did not do it as there was no intention to do so … it just happened that way.

        So maybe I will find myself one day no longer to be triggered in any flaw .. and passing a talking bolder just reacting … how are you today bolder, how did you come to speak.

        • Ronald

          I’m the same all the time. And I’ll tell you why because the Internet is a big nothing. Words are meaningless. I could write a thousand words and say nothing. And as you use words you’re doing nothing except using words so you’re not creating karma. If you react with anger you have to physically do something for it to be a reaction.Writing words is just writing words . You aren’t creating karma , if there is such a thing as karma. I don’t have online relationships because that means texting. You’re already withdrawn from your senses when you text. You might be in tune to your emotions and that’s possibly what’s frustrating because on a blog you’re talking to everyone and no one at the same time. You aren’t creating karma. There is no action or reaction at all . I like real sin and pleasure , not talking about it. And the same goes for meditation. The illusion and the grandeur of somebody who’s a narcissist saying that they understand Charan Singh and you don’t is beyond the pale. It’s honky white man talk.

        • Ronald

          Um , Spence the fence is not even fit to tie your shoelaces for you much less interpret Maharaji for you !

  6. Ronald

    You’ll never hear me criticize or degrade the real Guru , the Shabd. In fact just the opposite.

    • Spence Tepper

      When you stop denegrating anyone you begin to master withdrawl into Shabd. You can’t ride two horses going in opposite directions at the same time.

      And I suspect, for the same reason, you can’t be a decent guru either criticising anyone.

      • Ronald

        Okay and F U is why . Go tell someone else. It’s out of humility I don’t want to kick your ass. I’m no guru at all . Why would I want to be something I’ve been telling you are devil worshipers ? And you’re an example of the outcome and type of follower. Who would want that? Your master that’s who. go tell him. Tell him you’re the Big Man on campus. Idiot savant teaches idiot savant.

      • Ronald

        You must be full of Sound the way you denigrate everyone and not just gurus , you go after the nobodies like me 😭. I don’t need to withdraw into anything. I hear the Sound 24/7. That’s how great the Shabd master is ! I do nothing .

  7. Ronald

    Placebo, the man of little faith and much mouth.

  8. Ronald

    And let’s take a look at the followers of rssb while we’re bullshitting . I’ve known many and mostly. I’ve known them from their twenties up until their seventies and up until their death . And I’ve seen no difference between what happens to them in life and what happens to the uninitiated. Maybe it’s just because I know so many that have lost children to suicide that have lost parents , spouses and friends . But I don’t want to know Spence Tepper. He thinks he’s something special. I don’t do special. And if you take him as the end product of a satsangi or even one in the making , and I’m hearing the Sound as I say this , those people are full of shit. And don’t think for one minute that hearing the Sound is going to change the outcome of my karma either. I’m just enjoying the ride. I don’t ride horses anymore though. Bad back. And Spencer Tepper alias ” Placebo ” is bad luck.

    • Spence Tepper

      Grudge a bit there Ronald?

      • Ronald

        Not even. It’s your imagination a hole .I would never claim you as a follower and I don’t see Babaji doing it either. You’re a bad representation even if I’m the worst. At least you can eat me and you have no taste.

  9. Ronald

    Just because I’m in a fake guru’s last will and testament and he told me while he was still alive to start growing my beard , doesn’t make me a fake guru or guru at all. It makes me a truth teller. And I told GSD that he chose wrong when he chose me , since he said sometimes he chooses right and sometimes he chooses wrong. I get to live out the rest of my life with the pleasure of knowing that I was a wrong choice. But karma is karma. Otherwise he can take that dumb gurudom and shove it. People like Placebo will keep me out of satsang whether I’m a guru or not. I have no sense of duty. I’m not a cop or a military man. I can’t stand politicians so I won’t have to endorse anybody for my Dera. Yeah I’m still in GSD last will and testament because he’s too dumb to ever change his mind. But I listen to him and I listen to Gill some too because I listen to everybody. And two wrongs don’t make a right. And when you think about people that are jealous of love you think of placebo

    • Ronald

      Placenta is also something like a Placebo except after birth and I was wrong to call Spence Placenta because he hasn’t been born yet. And I don’t have to withdraw into anything I just have to quit texting. Bye

      • Ronald

        In fact I’m starting a petition to keep Spence Placebo Tepper off of the internet and this blog. Everyone who agrees comment below to show that this is not personal.

        • Ronald Dumbest

          It’s either him or me.

        • Donald Ray Hermes

          If Placebo Tepper had any real humility he would sign the petition himself !

          • Spence Tepper

            Who do you think gave you the idea, Ronald!
            You’re welcome!

            Yaeh something must go. How about your pride, your ego and your ignorance?

            I offer a three-for-one deal of the century!

            What’s the cost? Blaming anyone for anything.

            If you think that’s too expensive, consider the cost of continuing to choose ignorance.

        • La Madrugada

          I wholeheartedly agree and would sign the petition

          • Spence Tepper

            That’s the Trump ideal, don’t discuss, don’t think, get rid of those who don’t agree with you and be insulted by those who think differently and who seek real dialogue. Be threatened by a different idea. Got it.

            Then again a different idea might just be a step to getting rid of all that ego. I’d welcome it.

            Welcome being wrong. Your ego loses but your soul gains.

            I have to be wrong several times a day.

            Yeah it doesn’t always feel great. But you lose nothing.
            Sacrificing ignorance isn’t losing anything.

            It’s transforming you into something finer, washing you off dirt.

            Welcome it!
            I do!

  10. Ronald

    Here’s another favorite video posted by someone who I taught everything he knows in my last reincarnation but not everything I know. So I’m back to say the best thing Maharaji said is at the end. You’ll know when you’re hearing the Sound ! Talk is cheap
    https://youtu.be/xbI2FeoiNgk?si=xb2flXXTxdZLLxOk

    • Ronald

      I taught Maharaj Ji everything he knew but not everything I knew ( as Sawan Singh Ji ) 😂😂🙏😂😂

      • Spence Tepper

        Your humility is humbling, Ronald.
        😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *