Knowledge of God, or anything else, always must manifest in the physical brain

I love science. Always have. Always will. But for a long time I believed in a form of spiritual science, the notion that knowledge of supernatural entities, including God, could occur through a scientific approach to spirituality and religion.

Now I realize that I was mistaken. Not in an absolute certainty that before I was wrong, and now I am correct, because certainty isn’t the way of science. Just in a sense that there’s more reason to consider that a supernatural science can’t exist, since all knowledge manifests in the physical brain. Which obviously is natural, not supernatural.

I’ve started reading physicist Carlo Rovelli’s book, On the Equality of All Things: Lessons on Physics and Philosophy. That Amazon listing has a good summary of the book.

We are living in an age of scientific advancement on par with that of Copernicus, Galileo, and Newton: a period of discovery that has so fundamentally revolutionized our understanding of the world that it has shaken our most basic assumptions about who we are and our relationship to all things. In On the Equality of All Things, Carlo Rovelli turns his attention to this reckoning, bringing expertise and clarity to both the most mind-bending theories of modern physics and the most fundamental questions imaginable about the nature of time and existence.

Drawing from the latest advances in science and the teachings of modern and ancient philosophers, Rovelli invites us into the universe we thought we knew—one that is not made of things but of relationships. Time is a string of events, and there is no present time in the universe. Cause and effect are an illusion, and reality is an intricate and fragile web. And knowledge itself will always be imperfect, impermanent, and incomplete.

In a section on Certainty, Rovelli speaks of some basic facts about knowledge that most of us rarely think about, but seem highly likely to be true.

Think about these two statements: “Roberto is at home” and “Alice knows that Roberto is at home.” The first does not imply the second. Roberto could be at home without Alice knowing. But notice the subtle difference if I replace Alice with myself. In contrast to the previous case, if I state that “Roberto is at home,” I am also saying “I know that Roberto is at home” — otherwise how could I have said that he was there?

It’s a curious anomaly: the meaning of “to know” appears to change when the subject is “I.” Stating X is very different from stating “Alice knows X.” But stating X is not that different from saying “I know X”

The subtlety arises, as pointed out in the previous section, from the fact that there is no such thing as disembodied knowledge. Every assertion X is part of a knowledge, and this implies that there is something that possesses such knowledge and asserts X.

In other words, there is no disembodied language. The idea of a disembodied language is nothing more than, indeed, an idealization, which, as such, misses something. Language is itself part of reality, because there is always a speaker. Whether it is hidden or not, there is always this speaker, be it a human, a book, a carved stone, a computer.

There are no phrases that are not said, written, quoted, recorded, remembered, or in some other way embodied in the world. The phrase “Roberto is at home” is always pronounced, or thought, or affirmed by someone or something.

In other words, truth or knowledge isn’t floating around in some ethereal Platonic realm, divorced from our physical reality. The idea that there actually is disembodied truth or knowledge is itself a thought in the human brain. No one has ever shared a bit of truth or knowledge that wasn’t part of their physical brain. Never. Not once. Not ever.

Sure, those who believe in mysticism often consider that knowledge of the supernatural is ineffable, non-symbolic, impossible to express in words, thoughts, or any other form that can be communicated to other people. Okay. Perhaps that is true. Anything is possible. However, in that case supernatural knowledge can never be known by anyone other than the person who claims to have experienced it.

Which makes it just like a dream: real to the dreamer, unreal to anyone else. Well, actually supernatural knowledge would be even more unreal to anyone else, since the dreamer can try to describe what their dream was like, because dreams arise within the physical brain. But knowledge of the supernatural is considered to be disembodied knowledge — since the supernatural is disembodied.

In the previous section Rovelli referred to in the passage above, he says:

If Alice knows where Roberto is now, then there is something concrete in Alice’s brain — a physical process, a physical configuration — where this information is deposited. There is a certain process or configuration if Roberto is in Rome; a different process or configuration if he is in Bologna instead.

In other words, for us to have knowledge of the world, there must be physical correlations between ourselves and the world. In the same sense, for manuals, articles, or books — such as this book — to have knowledge of the world, there must be physical correlations  between them and the world. Thanks to these correlations, someone else, in principle, can learn about the world by asking us or by reading a book.

The key point I am stressing is that any information is necessarily and concretely embodied in a physical configuration. If Alice knows that Roberto is in Rome, then there is necessarily in Alice, as a physical system, something physical that is different from what would be there if Alice knew that Roberto was in Bologna.

Knowledge is a form of information. As such, it is a (particular form of) correlation between concrete physical parts of the world. So, knowledge is necessarily embodied in a physical configuration.

Someone claims to have knowledge of God. That knowledge must be embodied in their physical brain, in some sort of configuration. Question is, how could knowledge of something supernatural be embodied in something natural, the human brain? What connects the physical and supernatural? Hard to see how it could be physical. Also hard to see how it could be supernatural.

Most likely, those who claim to have knowledge of God are mistaken. They either are knowingly lying, or are fooling themselves. Every single bit of purported knowledge of the supernatural is communicated physically and naturally, not in some disembodied fashion. So if the supernatural exists, we humans can never know anything about it.


Discover more from Church of the Churchless

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

19 Comments

  1. Ron E.

    I get the basic premise about disembodied knowledge, and yes, a statement or phrase always implies someone or something. Even if Roberto only thinks or believes Alice is at home (she may be down the shops), the assertion, whether true or false, is still affirmed by someone or something.

    I can appreciate that we have made great advances in many spheres through the application of thought. But I appreciate more the countless things not created by thought – animals, plants, clouds, sunsets, air, rain, brains and bodies – things that we habitually take for granted without paying them much attention (until things go wrong!) and which we cannot exist without.

    It is also thought (brain) that creates the gurus and masters with their teachings and traditions handed down over numerous years, and it is thought that is our fears, hopes and wishes, insecurities and basically, the always constant thought that I am not satisfied with who/what I am and subsequently seeks some person, some institution that seems to offer the promise of making ‘me’ better.

    That is not to say that we should not try to improve a bad life situation, but what we truly want to achieve is a ‘me’ that is not subject to being a normal, natural biological creature with all the pains and fleeting pleasures and generally, all the ups and downs that go with being alive – and basically, the fear (the reality) that we will someday cease to exist.

  2. October

    What is real than reality around us?
    Who perceive the supernatural?
    Who Conceive the natural?

    These are fundamental questions
    Putting answers in language construct is impossible

    But one can definitely point out

    Hey… I am seeing this
    Can you see?

  3. Ronald

    ” When you hear the Sound you will know it .” I can’t think of anything more basic or more natural or more self-explanatory than what Maharaj Charan Singh said and obviously that’s not an experience exclusive solely to him or even people just in rssb . I have no interest at all in the supernatural. I’m interested in the natural real world and we’re told it’s only here and in the human form and now that we can achieve this so-called Sound. The human body is the laboratory and you can experiment with drugs and you can experiment with sex and you can experiment with science and art and meditation and then you can sleep for eternity. Maybe eternity is too supernatural to even use the term. So everybody just pays taxes and dies. I’m not interested in eternity. I’m interested in plant-based meat and potatoes. Meditation is for self confessed losers and after you’ve had enough of that you don’t even need to meditate to hear the natural rhythm and music of the Sound. Many people hear it don’t know what it is. They might confuse it with tinnitus or supernatural voices in the head or demons . And the way rssb has commercialized the process I’ll go with demons. My Sound is better than theirs

    • Um

      Sound of tinitus as described in literature does not resemble in anyway as the sant mat Sound are described … hissing is not the same as gongs, church bells or drums and is provoked by exposing to damaging Sound in the world.

      If tinitus is the same many artists and festival visitors hear the Sound that created the world.

      None of them likes it

      • Ronald

        Well that might be the one and only reason for the need of a teacher to tell them difference. The less it’s talked about and the less it’s thought about the better the chances of hearing it. It’s a gift to the pure of heart. Some people beg for lifetimes and never hear it. That’s what meditation is, begging. Begging for a gift is worse than buying it. And in the Punjab they’re doing both. Meanwhile just be a good person and I realize that’s impossible for some people. Especially the ones espousing it. The bad people are benefiting from your goodness. You have to fight fire with fire.

        • Um

          Mgs states that it is the same i can’t remember if mcs ever did

          Otherwise I do agree with what you wrote

          • Ronald

            Yeah in the video it looked and sounded like MCS didn’t want to stay in his body anymore but without a body then who is he? And as he said, where is he? He seemed to prove at least to himself that God doesn’t exist anywhere noticeable in the body or on the Earth . I don’t like his use of the term the Father because you can call it anything and I don’t like that term. It might scare people if they knew it wasn’t human and not found on Earth so Charan Singh used many biblical terms like God the Father . Terms I would never use . But nor did I ever see Brian Hines deny someone else’s personal experience whether it be outer or inner. I’ve never heard Brian criticize anything except the organization and institution of rssb that it’s become. And the narcissistic Guru who by the way wants a guru knows they’ve lost you then you win . And I agree with him on everything. He’s open-minded whereas many comments here aren’t.

          • Um

            It is remarkable how his voice, face and movements change with the one that asks.

            And … seeing the body language of his shadow, the “poor professor ” as he used to call him

            He seemed not to enjoy the ride

  4. Spence Tepper

    Brian, you conclude with
    “Most likely, those who claim to have knowledge of God are mistaken. They either are knowingly lying, or are fooling themselves. Every single bit of purported knowledge of the supernatural is communicated physically and naturally, not in some disembodied fashion. So if the supernatural exists, we humans can never know anything about it.”

    This has been your thesis for some time. But it falls a apart because the basis for this argument is subjective.

    Your entire argument rests on a false dichotomy between the “physical” and the “supernatural”: a divide that collapses the moment you look at how you actually experience anything.

    You claim that every bit of purported spiritual knowledge is communicated “physically and naturally.” Yet you have never once experienced a “physical” world outside of your own subjective awareness.

    What you call physical laws, matter, and objective reality are not things you touch directly; they are mental models, concepts, and images appearing inside your own consciousness.

    Even science is just human imagination disciplined by observation—a way of communicating our subjective impressions of patterns we perceive.

    Because all knowing is fundamentally subjective, you don’t stand on some privileged, purely “physical” ground looking out at delusional mystics.

    You are inside the exact same subjective arena as everyone else.

    Drawing a hard line between “natural” knowledge and “supernatural” illusion is entirely arbitrary.

    Both are experiences arising within consciousness.

    Dismissing someone else’s direct inner experience as lying or self-deception simply because it doesn’t fit your preferred mental model isn’t hard-headed realism. it’s just mistaking your own conceptual map for the whole of reality.

    And my map has a few more locations than yours.

    And probably a few less 😉

  5. Ronald

    It should say once a narcissist knows that they have lost you then you win. And believe me to the one experiencing the Sound, it’s not going to matter to them what anybody else thinks about it. 😂. There’s more strength in purity than there are in numbers.

    • Um

      Reading your words made me wonder if Mr T. hears it. ….. I believe he never mentioned it
      Not that matters … if he does it makes things even more ….

      • Spence Tepper

        Yes Um
        After all your past comments about my disclosures of my own inner experiences, I’m surprised you would wonder.

        The Shabd is central. It is life living moment by moment, always present and interrupting my distractions, calling me to return to hear and now, where Master always waits for me, smiling.

        When I return to the hear and now, there is Shabd resounding in the skies, and Master.

        And it is part also of our meditation.

        When you hear it, when it transforms as you enter it, and becomes resounding, like standing in the church tower as the mighty bell tolls, so loud it is painful, yet filled with bliss, and brilliant, blinding light, so bright it is painful, but filled with joy, all for the cost of just contemplating your Master, doing a little simran to Him, then of course, all you want to do is protect that, build your life around that.

        And death is now something different, living through moments without that, without Master’s company is being dead, asleep.

        And what was physical death becomes a meaningless concept. A human distinction that doesn’t really exist. It’s just a part of who we are, old clothes sewn in a flawed and dark past.

        And that is where the real journey begins.

        It is a sin to hide that truth. I cannot. But it is also a hardship to speak of it to those with no exposure.

        Of course they would try to package that as a mental issue. Understood.

        But, to paraphrase Phillip K.Dick and Brian, for those of us living in it, it is the one reality that doesn’t go away no matter what we think, say or do.

        It is more persistent than the sky, the sun, the stars, all those around us, all our own opinions about it, and even our opinions about Master.

        Inner Master and Nam persists, and grows in force and power as our opinions disappear.

        And that is how we learn how fickle and fleeting is our persona, our ego, our parochial judgment, our opinions, and this fleeting life.

        The reality seen through these biochemical sense recreations of the brain is living life seeing and hearing their a turbulent sea, entirely pieced together and poorly imagined and recreated.

        In contrast direct perception is incredible, and the first of these is Shabd and Master.

        Try it. Try to be as persistent in your practice of meditation, of Master’s Presence, as your fickle perception of reality.

        Be persistent. Be real. A few years being fickle doesn’t justify more of the same fickle non-reality, Um.

        But a single life in regular and reliable devotion may open the door to that unwavering reality that puts us all to shame: the Master’s gift of Nam, and the unwavering grace of his ever present smile.

        Is it madness? To you, to some.

        But it is my reality. And so, it should be respected, just as each of us asks that our reality be respected.

        You don’t have to defend your reality to have it respected as real for you, Um. Nor does anyone else.

        That’s easier to do when folks aren’t blaming others.
        I don’t mind honoring someone’s temporary ignorance if they aren’t throwing rocks at others.

        • Um

          I just wondered and after reading your answer I even more.

          I can’t experience anything authentic in it … it sounds like a textbook declaration or the sermon of a priest.

          That doesn’t mean you are not speaking your truth.

          What I could confirm for myself with regard to sant mat is what I could see with my eyes and hear with my ears and many of the things he spoke about with regard to human activities … as I wrote before .. he was a great psychologist …otherwise did not have any experience and lack all the requisites to walk this path.

          And that is allright.

          Whatever longing and curiosity I ever might have had has long time ago gone….these days spirituality is one of the many things people engage in .. like cricket …a game of which I can only write the word and know that Indians are fond of it

          People having experiences impress me as much as Brian driving a tesla … not being jealous by nature I hope they enjoy what they have.

          Things people have can easily become a wooden block at their legs …they need not … they easily do

          • Um

            And … I do not turn my head with frustration…not at all.

            Through my association I came to know so many kind people of all walks of life, from whom I learned many a thing.

            Even now I am re-casing a book by the Hon. Dr. Stone … without that association … I would not have known about polarity therapy, shaked hands with the man and talked with him and not know about bookbinding.

  6. Spence Tepper

    Hi Um
    It’s a very positive thing that you appreciate in your own way, that you honor, what you have been able to learn and verify from your exposure to a few other people and their ideas. Of course that does require accepting that others might know something you don’t. If they are good teachers for you, that becomes very easy. That’s a good fit.

    Sometimes they may say things you don’t want to hear. That doesn’t disqualify their advice. Might be just what you need to hear.

    But if you can’t accept it, that might disqualify them as your mentor.

    Knowing a truth and presenting it well are two different things. And being able to accept and digest their words with appreciation also doesn’t reflect on that truth. It may just reflect on how good of a student we actually are.

    Dialogue works when we a have that attitude to learn, not to judge what we may not know understand yet.

    Despite your experience or mine, we can still learn from each other. I think that’s a standard we should all strive for.

    Neither of us have to be perfect. We aren’t. We are all students still learning new lessons every day. Still, we can learn from one another.

    Freshmen assume the graduate students should know it all. They judge with very simplistic standards. They think poorly of graduate students struggling at their own studies.

    But that struggle at each level is in fact what it is to be a student, growing to be a better student.

    When freshmen try to judge graduate students, it is a futile exercise filled with inaccuracy.

    But the same is true of the graduate students looking at the freshmen.

    Just keeping up with our own studies is a full time job.

    Being a good graduate student is still being a struggling student, one who can and does fail. And often. But they learn from each failure.

    Every good scientist is a professional at failure. They accept it as the price of trying, testing and learning.

    Failure, even embarrassment, even public humiliation is their companion, as they make progress.

    They see the freshmen have little exposure or comfort for that. That innocence is touching.

    But they will learn in time.

    Being a graduate student also doesn’t qualify them as teachers.

    Only a few graduate students have those skills. They aren’t actually necessary to graduate and practice.

    A teacher is a very specialized role and not all of us are cut out for it. That burden is nearly unimaginable.

    But thankfully, it has little to do with being a successful student.

  7. Um

    That is your world, your path … that is allright.

    Those that I met were not teaching anything… I learned from their example … by observing… and I did my thing with it … in a sense I was nobodies student.

    So I became knowledgeable about many things without having them, being involved with it …my late friend invited me one day to paint some majolica to see whether I had ” a hand ” for it and after a quarter of an hour he said that he would love to teach the art, based on what he saw … I refused …. have learned their in his atelier many, many things …things that all serve me today …. hahaha …there are many ways to master things … and some are not visible, can not be exploited …. haha

    And that was just one of a long list

    Birds are born with a song. In order to sing they learn to sing. The trap is to get stuck in learning etc etc. Realizing at the end of life that the song was never sung … this song …

    But you do your thing …

    • Um

      Hahaha … making coffee….something mcs said once to me:
      Rolling stones don’t gather moss.

      Today I take it out of his historical context and use it anew here ….. hahaha … by rolling … the stone remains who and what he is …carrying no identity …. professional, social, political, religious, cultural ….hahaha

      • Spence Tepper

        Hi Um:
        That’s great if you like being bald.
        A little moss is great, if you don’t mind green hair!

        Adult learning is another very complex topic. Adults don’t like to be taught: “Death Before Directions”.

        It’s a whole professional field. According to the experts in Andragogy), adults learn best when you treat them like capable partners rather than empty vessels. I’ve never been very good at that. I’m still a child, so starting as an empty vessel is my first duty as a student.

        But adults generally all ready have an idea of the subject, and they bring a wealth of their own experience to the table, so they immediately want to know why a topic matters and how it solves real-world problems right now. And if it doesn’t solve what they perceive they need, interest evaporates.

        Adult learners often think they already know a subject, and may only have a question about a single point. They want things boiled down so they can either accept (25% of the time) or reject it against their own criteria. If they do accept it they don’t want to hear anything more on the subject for now.

        It’s just a thing, a reality. Encouraging adults to think like children is a marginal strategy, I get it.

        It works for me because I’m an eternal child who doesn’t remember his own worldly experience or past until others remind me. I’m preoccupied with a different experience 🙂 So if you call me a three-year-old I can only agree.

        Then, asked for details, the words and details come back in a flood. But I don’t live with words unless I’m interacting with the world.

  8. Um

    I seriously doubt what you wrote in the last two sentences.

    It might be due to my drinking coffee that my brain and guts do not function well, but these two sentences do not correspond at all with the overall atmosphere of your answers that lack the spontaneity of a child.

    Your words tell about a well trained and harnessed person … a verbal commando type… drill sergant… no doubt very skilled
    … but I cannot recognize a child or liveliness in it.

    Not that it matters .. this is just how I perceive it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *